Wednesday, 11 March 2026

Bharat: Status Quoism or Dynamism?

 

While examining the Indian nation through the concept of “parampara” (tradition) as articulated by Prof. Ram Shevalkar, the second part traced the traditions of Vashistha and Vishwamitra in the context of the question: the path of knowledge or the path of statecraft?

In this part, we will examine another question, stability or dynamism, that is, “To be Static or to Adopt Dynamism” through the traditions of Bhargava and Narayaniya.

Bhargav or Bhrigu: 


Sage Bhrigu, like Vashistha, is also considered a Manasaputra of Brahma. According to Indian Puranic literature, these sages are born again in different Manvantaras.

According to the Vishnu Purana, in the first Manvantara Bhrigu married Khyati. They had children such as Ayati, Niyati, and Bhargavi (Lakshmi). Among them, Lakshmi was married to Vishnu.

According to the Shiva Purana, after the episode of Daksha Yajna and Sati, Bhrigu received a boon that he would be reborn in the Chakshusha Manvantara. Accordingly, he was reborn and in this birth married Puloma.

The Bhagavata Purana narrates the well-known Trinity episode. During a Yajña (sacrificial ritual), a dispute arose regarding who among Brahma, Vishnu, and Mahesh (Shiva) was supreme. The sages could not reach a conclusion, and the responsibility of deciding the matter was given to Bhrigu.

Bhrigu first went to Satyaloka, to Brahma. To test his own father, he did not offer salutations. Brahma became angry.

Then he went to Kailasa. Shiva came forward warmly to greet his friend, but Bhrigu said, “You are adharmic.” Shiva grew enraged and raised his trishul. The situation was pacified only through the intervention of Parvati.

Finally, Bhrigu went to Vaikuntha. Vishnu was resting with his head on Lakshmi’s lap. Bhrigu kicked Vishnu on the chest. Vishnu and Lakshmi were startled. Bhrigu expected Vishnu to become angry, but instead Vishnu apologized, saying that he had failed to notice Bhrigu’s arrival.

The verdict was clear: Vishnu was the greatest.

Another story appears in the Matsya Purana.

During a war between the Devas and Asuras, the Asuras were defeated and sought refuge with Shukracharya. Shukracharya decided to perform penance to obtain power and boons from Shiva. Until then, the Asuras sought refuge in the ashrama of Bhrigu, where Puloma granted them protection.

The Devas attacked. Under Puloma’s protection they could do nothing. Eventually Vishnu was invoked, and with the Sudarshana Chakra he killed Puloma.

Bhrigu was enraged and cursed Vishnu:

“You have committed the sin of killing a woman. Therefore you shall take birth again and again in the mortal world.” (A Puranic inception point for Dashavtar.)

Among the descendants of Bhrigu and Puloma was Chyavana, and in that lineage later appeared Jamadagni and Parashurama. From here begins the Bhargava tradition relevant to our discussion.

The Pinaka bow of Shiva, which had been given to Parashurama, was entrusted to King Janaka for safekeeping. During Sita’s swayamvara, Shri Rama broke this bow.

If we interpret this episode symbolically, Pinaka represents Sanatana Dharma and its foundational principles. Protecting it was the task of Parashurama, a position of preserving stability. The aim was that the essential principles of dharma and tradition should remain intact.

But the bow was broken.

Therefore, a confrontation occurred between Parashurama and Shri Rama. In that encounter, Parashurama was defeated by Rama. In a symbolic sense, this represents the victory of the Narayaniya tradition, dynamism, over the Bhargava tradition of stability.

Thus, on one side stands the stability-oriented Bhargava tradition, and on the other the dynamic Narayaniya tradition.

Narayaniya:


Yet the seeds of the Narayaniya Parampara are already present in Bhrigu’s curse itself. The idea of repeated births in the mortal world symbolizes dynamism, adaptability, and the capacity to evolve. It is also a symbol of assimilation and integration.

This Parampara manifests itself in many ways across Indian sects and philosophical streams. And because the spirit of assimilation is inherent, the question of accepting only Bhargava (stability) or only Narayaniya (dynamism) does not arise. Coexistence remains constant.

The Matsya, Vishnu, and Bhagavata Puranas further develop the concept of Vishnu’s avatars. A careful examination suggests that these narratives represent an attempt to assimilate diverse communities of the Indian subcontinent who worshipped different animals, forms, and divine powers, integrating them into the broader civilizational framework.

The Ramayana narrates the journey of Shri Rama from Ayodhya to Lanka, a journey that brings into the fold communities such as the Nishada king, Shabari, the Vanaras, and others, integrating them into a shared civilizational ethos.

The Mahabharata describes the journey of Shri Krishna from Dwaraka to Pragjyotishapura and beyond, similarly integrating diverse regions and communities.

The teachings of Tathagata Buddha began spreading across regions even during his lifetime. During the Mauryan period, Buddhism received royal patronage. With this support and the prosperity of trade networks, Buddhist thought spread to Sri Lanka, Burma, and through the Silk Route to Central Asia.

During the same era, India witnessed invasions by Persians, Greeks, Shakas, Kushans, and Huns. Many of them established kingdoms. Yet the Narayaniya tradition exerted its influence, the invaders gradually assimilated and became Indian.

Menander became Milinda.

Shaka rulers adopted names such as Rudradaman.

The Kushan rulers convened a Buddhist council in Kashmir.

With the maritime powers of South India, Buddhist and Hindu ideas together travelled to East and Southeast Asia. There they assimilated with local traditions and cultures. Empires such as Srivijaya and Kambuja emerged. The largest temple complex in the world, Angkor Wat, stands there as testimony.

The Bhargava and Narayaniya traditions can also be found at different stages and in different forms within Indian traditions such as Jainism and Buddhism.

In Buddhism, over time, sectarian distinctions arose, Theravada (the conservative or original school), Mahayana, and Vajrayana.

The Theravada tradition strives to remain faithful to the original teachings of the Buddha. The stupa stands as the symbol of nirvana, knowledge, and the Tathagata.

The Mahayana tradition, however, expands its scope. It presents the Tathagata in human form, creating statues depicting various mudras, Dhyana, Abhaya, Bhumisparsha, Varada, and Vitarka. The Jataka tales, in a sense, parallel the idea of the Dashavatara.

A further development of this is the tantric-influenced Vajrayana tradition seen prominently in Tibet. Similar processes of evolution and variation can also be observed in Jain and other traditions.

However, at a later stage, a militant wave of invasions emerged with a firm theological position: there is only one God - Allah, and Muhammad is his final and only prophet. Whether due to the weakening of the Narayaniya assimilative tradition or the intensity of the invaders’ zeal, this force could not be assimilated. In fact, assimilation was never its intent.

The title “Butshikan” (idol-breaker) was, and remains, a badge of honour for such forces.

In such circumstances, there remains only one path:

To study our Sanatana traditions, ancient, eternal, unbroken, and ever-renewing, from multiple perspectives; to understand the religion and psychology of the aggressors; and to preserve our own civilizational continuity.

While attempting to understand these traditions from the perspective of parampara, I am fully aware that what has been presented here is only a preliminary introduction to these streams. A deeper analysis is necessary and will continue.

For now, I conclude here.

Lekhanseema. 

Bharat: Jñānamārga & Rajamarga

While examining the idea of the Indian nation through the concept of “Parampara” as articulated by Prof. Ram Shevalkar, in the first we part briefly reviewed India as a civilization and culture, and concluded by identifying the Parampara that form its foundation. These Parampara are Vashistha, Vishwamitra, Bhargava, and Narayaniya.

In this part, we shall explore Vashistha and Vishwamitra Parampara with the question: Is the path of the nation guided primarily by the path of knowledge or by the path of statecraft and power?

Vashishtha:

Sage Vashistha, considered the Manasaputra of Brahma, is the bearer of the Brahmadanda, the staff of spiritual authority, and the embodiment of knowledge. He is counted among the 21 Prajapatis and served as the Rajpurohit (Royal Preceptor) of the Ikshvaku dynasty of Lord Rama.

Vashishtha

Following the command of King Dasharatha, Sage Vashistha imparted guidance to Rama and Lakshmana on justice, ethics, and the principles of an ideal state. This teaching is known as Yoga Vashistha.

The Treta Yuga is unique: on one hand, it witnesses the incarnation of Parashurama, and on the other, it strengthens the ideals of an ideal kingdom, family, and social order.

The Dasharajna War described in the Rigveda is the earliest known great war. Ten royal clans, comprising both Arya and non-Arya groups, formed a confederacy against Sudās Paijavana, the king of the Bharata lineage. The Kulaguru and priest of the Bharatas was Sage Vashistha.

Vishwamitra:

Vishwamitra

On the other side stands Vishwamitra, a Kshatriya king from the lineage of King Kaushika, who ruled Kanyakubja. 

Skilled in governance and warfare, he nevertheless possessed a deep yearning for Brahma-Jnana. Pursuing this quest, he undertook intense penance. Through prolonged austerities and devotion, Brahma himself conferred upon Vishwamitra, originally a Rajarshi, the title of Brahmarshi.

He is revered as the seer of the Gayatri Mantra and one of the great seers of the Rigveda.

In the context of the present discussion, an important aspect is the long-standing conflict between Vashistha and Vishwamitra.

Once, while hunting, Vishwamitra arrived at Vashistha’s hermitage and requested the divine cow Kamadhenu. Vashistha refused. Using the power of the Brahmadanda and Kamadhenu, Vashistha defeated Vishwamitra and his entire army. Unable to accept this humiliation, Vishwamitra undertook severe penance, pleased Lord Shiva, and obtained divine weapons.

At another time, King Trishanku developed the ambition to ascend to heaven in his mortal body. For this, a Yajna  (grand sacrifice) was required. He wished the ritual to be performed under the priesthood of Vashistha. When Vashistha refused, the enraged Trishanku approached Vishwamitra.

Vishwamitra accepted the priesthood and performed the sacrifice. Trishanku was sent towards heaven but could not enter it. When the situation spiraled beyond control, Vishwamitra boldly challenged the cosmic order and created a counter-creation (a parallel heaven).

His penance continued relentlessly, and eventually Brahma granted him the title of Brahmarshi. Vashistha too acknowledged this title, forgiving Vishwamitra’s earlier confrontations.

This reconciliation is also reflected in the Ramayana: when Vishwamitra requested Rama and Lakshmana for protecting his sacrifice and for imparting knowledge of divine weapons and warfare, Sage Vashistha approved the request.

Returning to the Dasharajna War, the confederation of ten kings against the Bharata clan included groups such as Anu and Druhyu, and also the Kaushika lineage from which Vishwamitra emerged. Later, through penance, Vishwamitra attained the status of Brahmarshi.

The Bharatas eventually emerged victorious. Sudās Paijavana became a Chakravarti and performed the Ashwamedha Yajña.

The priest of that sacrifice was, Brahmarshi Vishwamitra!

From this narrative we can clearly understand who Vashistha and Vishwamitra were, the nature of their relationship, and their defining characteristics. Based on this understanding, we can move to a broader interpretation.

The Vashistha tradition represents the Jñānamārga (The Path Prioritizing Knowledge over Kshatra). It is characterized by forgiveness, the pursuit of knowledge, the celebration of penance, and the recognition of spiritual accomplishment. This tradition flows continuously through Upanishadic and Puranic discourse and through the civilizational pursuit of knowledge.

Ancient Indian universities and their traditions of scholarship are prime examples of this knowledge tradition. It emphasizes the creation of ideal models of life and society.

At times, this tradition also flows toward a renunciatory current. Its reflection can be seen in the Bhakti movement, widely spread through the Advaita Vedanta of Adi Shankaracharya.

This Bhakti movement manifests across regions:

in the South through Tyagaraja, Purandaradasa, and the Madhvacharya tradition,

in Maharashtra through the unbroken Varkari Sampradaya,

in the East through the movement of Shankaradeva,

and in the North through figures such as Haridas, Meera, Tulsidas, and even the Sikh tradition.

Moving into the modern era, echoes of this tradition can also be seen in two different ideological streams with somewhat similar objectives.

One is Mahatma Gandhi’s concept of Sarvodaya. Its programs and frameworks were contextual and time-bound; as circumstances changed, that stream gradually receded.

The other is the movement of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). Based on ideas such as Nation First, Integral Humanism, and Cultural Nationalism, it focuses on character-building and nation-building and continues to function actively.

The Vijaynagar Samrajya

The Vishwamitra tradition, by contrast, represents the Rajamarga (path of statecraft and power). It is the journey from Rajarshi to Brahmarshi. It is a tradition that challenges the prevailing order and, if necessary, possesses the audacity to create an alternative order.

The first historical figure that naturally comes to mind in this context is Acharya Chanakya. Realizing that the existing rulers were incapable, or unwilling, to protect the nation from foreign invasions, he mobilized Chandragupta Maurya and laid the foundation of a new empire.

India faced numerous foreign invasions. Until roughly the 8th century, India largely absorbed these invaders, assimilating them into its cultural framework. However, later invasions were accompanied by forces that insisted on maintaining separateness.

The first decisive intellectual challenge to such forces once again came from Adi Shankaracharya.

The Varkari Sampradaya is predominantly a path of devotion and renunciation. Yet within the same tradition, Sant Eknath, during the decline of the Vijayanagara Empire, openly advocated the need for a Hindu polity.

As Sant Eknath’s era was coming to an end, another figure from an entirely different order, Samarth Ramdas, emerged, articulating even more clearly and directly the aspiration for a Hindu state. Significantly, he also lived to witness that state come into existence.

This confluence of traditions is a distinctive feature of Indian civilization.

The first inspiration for re-establishing a Hindu kingdom after resisting Islamic invasions came from Vidyaranya Swami, whose vision materialized in the Vijayanagara Empire.

That same current of thought later flowed through the Bhosale lineage, from Shahaji Maharaj to Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and Chhatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj.


Under Islamic rule, a widespread belief had taken hold that no Kshatriya remained, and therefore no Hindu king could be ritually crowned. Challenging this assumption, Gaga Bhatt established Shivaji Maharaj’s Kshatriya lineage and commanded, almost as a sacred injunction, that he be crowned Chhatrapati.

This intellectual stream continues into the British era. When certain ideological currents began asserting that Muslims constituted a separate nation, Vinayak Damodar Savarkar articulated the political idea of a Hindu Rashtra, drawing inspiration from the geographical definition of India found in the Vishnu Purana:

उत्तरं यत् समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम् ।

वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः ॥

(Uttaraṁ yat samudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam

Varṣaṁ tad bhārataṁ nāma bhāratī yatra santatiḥ)

And, 

आसिंधु सिंधूपर्यंता यस्य भारतभूमिका

पितृभू पुण्यभूश्चैव स वै हिंदूरिती स्मृतः

(Āsindhu sindhuparyantā yasya bhāratabhūmikā

Pitṛbhū puṇyabhūścaiva sa vai hinduriti smṛtaḥ)

Savarkar gave this civilizational definition a political dimension.

From this entire discussion, one important point becomes clear: these traditions are not in conflict. The real question is one of priority, the path of knowledge or the path of statecraft?

In reality, when the Rajamarga establishes a stable and capable state, the Jñānamarga flourishes. If both traditions move forward in parallel, the question of choosing between knowledge and power ceases to exist.

In the next part, we will examine the Bhargava and Narayaniya traditions through their various historical streams.


Stay Tuned..... 

Bharat: A Civilizational Journey Through Parampara - Opening Reflection

 

In his celebrated lecture series on Yogeshwar Shri Krishna, the eminent scholar and orator Vakta Dashasahasreshu Prof. Ram Shewalkar introduces the concept of “Parampara” (Tradition) in a profound sense. 

By parampara, he does not merely refer to rituals, worship practices, vows, or social customs. Rather, he speaks of it in a much wider and deeper sense, as the civilizational, social, political, and cultural core of the Indian nation.

While interpreting the life and philosophy of Shri Krishna, Prof. Shewalkar briefly elaborates upon this idea of tradition. Taking that thread forward, this is an attempt to understand the Bharat through the lens of parampara.

When the word “Bharat” is uttered, what immediately comes to my mind is the description of the land of Bharat and its people found in the Vishnu Purana:

उत्तरं यत् समुद्रस्य हिमाद्रेश्चैव दक्षिणम्।

वर्षं तद् भारतं नाम भारती यत्र संततिः।।

(Uttaraṁ yat samudrasya himādreścaiva dakṣiṇam |

Varṣaṁ tad Bhārataṁ nāma Bhāratī yatra santatiḥ ||)

The land that lies to the north of the ocean and to the south of the Himalayas is called Bharat, and those who dwell there are known as Bharatiyas.

This, of course, is a geographical definition. But Bharat transcends geography. It is a civilizational continuum, a cultural current that has been flowing since the times of the Sindhu–Saraswati civilization and the Vedic age.

Kings came and went. Political systems rose and fell. Yet the civilizational core remained unchanged. The spirit expressed in the Vedic dictum, “Ekam sat vipra bahudha vadanti” (Truth is one, the wise call it by many names) continues to endure.

The roots are deep. The trunk is strong. Numerous branches have emerged and expanded over time, yet they all remain connected to the same living tree of civilization.

The sentiment of Bharatiya cultural nationalism has always been strong, and it is our collective responsibility to keep that spirit alive and vibrant. In reflecting upon this, we must also take into account the observations from the book “The Cultural History of Ancient India” by R. N. Gayadhani and V. G. Rahurkar, which state:

“History, in the Indian view, is a cultural inheritance that guides the present generation and shapes the future.”

They further observe:

“Indian civilization regards time as beginningless and endless. The precise dating of events has often seemed secondary; what truly matters is the record of human endeavour inscribed upon the canvas of time.”

And finally:

“An individual does not create culture; rather, culture inevitably shapes the life of the individual.”

Keeping this entire cultural canvas in mind, we must now return to our central theme, examining the Bharatiya nation through the perspective of tradition (parampara).

According to Prof. Ram Shewalkar, four major traditions emerge within the civilizational journey of Bharat:

The Vasistha Parampara, beginning with Rishi Vasistha, the royal priest of the Kosala kingdom and the author of the Yoga Vasistha.

The Vishwamitra Parampara, beginning with Rajarshi Vishwamitra, the seer of Rigvedic hymns and the creator of a “counter-creation”.

The Bhargava Parampara, originating from Rishi Bhrigu, one of the Saptarishis and among the Prajapatis created by Brahma.

And the Narayaneya Parampara, which traces its origin to Lord Vishnu himself.

What exactly do these traditions represent?

Where and how do their reflections appear across ancient and modern Indian history?

We shall explore these questions in the next part.


Stay tuned...

Friday, 20 February 2026

Mestak: Decolonizing Bharat the Maratha Way

Hemadri Pandit.

Decolonisation is not merely the removal of foreign political power. It is the restoration of intellectual confidence. It is the recovery of systems. It is the reclaiming of institutional memory.

The Maratha Empire did not simply challenge imperial authority on the battlefield; it reconstructed the civilizational backbone of Bharat. At the heart of that reconstruction lay something deeply profound yet often overlooked: the revival of the ancient Indic tradition of accounting and state book-keeping embodied in the concept of मेस्तक (Mestak).

What is Mestak?

Mestak was a structured accounting manuscript tradition, a codified format for recording state revenue and expenditure. But more than that, it was a philosophy of governance.

The preserved shloka states:

लेखकासी हे मेस्तक। नीतिवंता नीतिशास्त्र देखा।

राजकी लोकांसि विवेक। प्रकट करी।।

लेखणी दिधली ज्याचे हाती। तो स्वीकारिला सरस्वती।

लेखनकळा वर्षा आरती। साधली तया I आताही जे असता धरिती

येणेप्रमाणे लिहिती। त्यासी पावेल सरस्वती। संदेह नाही।।

Simply stated, Mestak belongs to the scribe and is governed by ethical discipline and established rules. It must uphold fairness toward both the king and the people. Writing must be controlled, precise, and disciplined. Records must be carefully verified and accountable. Those who follow these principles shall be blessed by Saraswati.

The text contains elaborate and highly technical codifications of bookkeeping and accounting practices. For those who wish to explore this subject in depth, I strongly recommend the remarkable work 13th Century to 18th Century by Dr. Anjali Sanjay Vekhande.


It is only fair to acknowledge that it was this book that sparked my curiosity and inspired me to delve deeper into the subject, leading me to explore the profound legacy of Mestak and the administrative genius of our civilizational tradition.

To understand this revival is to understand how decolonising the mind is both possible and practical.

The Interrupted Civilizational Continuum:

Ancient Bharat was not a civilization without systems. The Arthashastra, the Smriti literature, the Dharmashastric traditions, and regional administrative manuals all testify to a sophisticated fiscal order. State accounting, treasury management, land surveys, and revenue classification were not colonial imports; they were civilizational inheritances.

From the Yadava dynasty to the Deccan polities, a lineage of administrative science evolved. Hemadri Pandit’s influence in the Yadava period represents one such institutional continuity.

Hemadri Pandit, popularly known as Hemadpant, served as the Shrikarandhip (Chief Revenue Officer, often equated with prime ministerial authority) under the Yadava rulers of Devagiri in the 13th century. He was not merely an administrator but a true polymath of medieval Bharat.

On one hand, he systematised and popularised the Bhumij style of Nagara temple architecture, leaving behind an enduring architectural imprint across the Deccan. On the other, he authored the monumental treatise “Chaturvarga Chintamani,” an encyclopaedic compendium on Dharma, Shastra, ritual law, and civil order.

Equally significant, though less widely acknowledged, was his codification of principles of bookkeeping and accounting in a structured administrative manual known as मेस्तक (Mestak).

Centuries later, during the Peshwai period of the Maratha Empire, this administrative legacy was consciously revived and recomposed. Manuscripts were rediscovered in Modi script and later found, studied, and published by Itihasacharya V.K. Rajwade. In the revived text, the importance of Hemadri Pandit and Mestak is acknowledged through the following verses:

अप्रसिद्ध जगामाजी। पिशाच लिपी हे योजी।

जीणे प्रतिष्ठा समाजी। विप्र पावती।

ऐसा अनागत द्रष्टा। हेमाद्री नामप्रतिष्ठा। योजुन ठेविली।।

त्यासी साष्टांगी नमन। करुनिया ग्रंथारंभण।

केले रिघोनि शरण। लेखक जनासी।।

These verses express that Hemadri Pandit’s administrative wisdom, once obscure and nearly forgotten, was consciously revived. The later compilers acknowledge him as a visionary whose codified system of accounting had endured the test of time. They begin their work with reverence, offering salutations and aligning themselves with his intellectual lineage.

However, prolonged foreign rule disrupted this organic development. Administrative structures shifted. Indigenous intellectual traditions were sidelined. Persianate bureaucratic practices replaced native record-keeping languages like Modi. The degradation was not merely political; it was systemic and epistemic.

This is the undercurrent that must be acknowledged: the Maratha resurgence was not only about sovereignty; it was about restoring the indigenous grammar of governance.

The Maratha Resolve: Restoration, Not Reaction

When Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj established Swarajya, he did not merely build forts and lead campaigns. He reconstructed administration. He revived institutional ethics. He reintroduced disciplined record-keeping.

Annaji Datto initiated land revenue reforms rooted in precision and accountability. Surveys were conducted meticulously. Records were preserved systematically in Modi script. Financial registers were maintained with clarity.

This was not imitation of European models. It was the revival of an Indic lineage.

And this revival took shape in the form of Mestak.

From Arthashastra to the Marathas: The Restoration of a Civilizational Lineage

The story of Mestak begins not with the Marathas but with the civilizational foundations of Bharat. From Kautilya’s Arthashastra, which established treasury management, audit, and fiscal ethics as instruments of sovereignty, this lineage flowed through the Dharmashastras into Deccan administrative traditions, where Hemadri Pandit codified these principles in Mestak under the Yadavas of Devagiri. Though prolonged foreign rule disrupted and obscured this indigenous system, it was the Marathas who restored this broken chain of institutional continuity.

The Radical Shift: From King to State

One of the most transformative developments under the Marathas was the shift from the income and expenditure of the king to the income and expenditure of the state. This was not a minor procedural change. It marked the emergence of institutional governance.

The treasury ceased to be the personal purse of the ruler. The state became a juridical entity distinct from the sovereign. Fiscal responsibility became public, structured, and documented.

In modern terminology, this is the foundation of public finance accountability.

Under Chhatrapati Shahu Maharaj and later under the Peshwas, Nanasaheb, Madhavrao, and Administrator Nana Phadnavis, this administrative philosophy matured. The revived Mestak tradition refined revenue classification. Expenditure heads were codified. Documentation became systematic. Accountability was institutionalised.

Colonial historiography often suggests that structured accounting entered India through European influence, frequently citing Luca Pacioli’s 1494 double-entry system as the beginning of modern bookkeeping.

The Marathas did not reject innovation; they revived tradition and adapted it to contemporary needs. They demonstrated that modern governance need not erase indigenous roots.

Decolonising the administrative mind begins by recognising that the grammar of institutional accountability in India has its own genealogy.

The revival of Mestak was not merely a fiscal correction; it was an act of cultural and intellectual reclamation.

By restoring the use of Modi script in official records, reinforcing Bharatiya administrative autonomy, and reintroducing Dharmashastric ethical frameworks into governance, the Marathas reinterpreted ancient norms for contemporary statecraft.

Strengthening institutions over personalities through a clear separation between office and individual; embedding ethical accountability within financial systems; teaching Arthashastra, Hemadri’s codifications, and Maratha administrative traditions alongside global frameworks; reviving archival literacy and indigenous scripts to rebuild institutional memory; and training civil servants in India’s own governance heritage to cultivate rooted confidence.

Decolonisation, therefore, is not symbolic assertion; it is systematic restoration. They did not romanticise the past; they operationalised it with institutional clarity. That very template offers a practical roadmap for contemporary Bharat.

The Way Forward: Re-anchoring Modernity

If the Marathas in the 17th and 18th centuries could restore ancient institutional systems under politically hostile and unstable conditions, there is no reason 21st-century India cannot reclaim intellectual sovereignty in an era defined by global interconnectedness. Their example reminds us that civilizational confidence does not emerge from isolation but from rootedness.

Re-anchoring modernity does not mean rejecting IFRS, global accounting standards, or international regulatory frameworks. It means recognising that structured accounting, ethical treasury management, and the separation of ruler and state were embedded in our own traditions long before colonial mediation. Modern systems can be engaged with confidence when they are integrated into a civilizationally grounded foundation.

The quest, therefore, is not to romanticise the past; it is to stabilise the future by reconnecting it to its own lineage. 

The Marathas demonstrated that civilizational memory can be revived after disruption, that systems can be restored with discipline, that governance can be both ethical and indigenous, and that accounting can achieve technical precision without losing moral grounding.

In this light, Mestak becomes more than a manuscript tradition; it becomes a metaphor. It symbolises accountability rooted in ethics, discipline anchored in duty, institutional sovereignty beyond personalities, cultural self-assurance in administration, and revival after historical degradation. It represents the continuity of a civilization that refused to forget its own grammar of governance.

Decolonising Bharat, therefore, is not an abstract slogan. It is a structured, actionable process, sector by sector, institution by institution, discipline by discipline. True sovereignty lies not merely in territorial control but in systemic control: in the ability to measure honestly, record faithfully, audit rigorously, and govern according to civilizational values.

The path forward is clear and practical: reclaim the lineage, restore the systems, reinterpret the tradition, and  nstitutionalize integrity. That was the Maratha way. And it remains the pathway toward a confident, rooted, and future-ready Bharat.


Thursday, 4 December 2025

मऱ्हाटीची बोलू कौतुके

छायाचित्र सौजन्य: इंटरनेट 

अर्थाचा अनर्थ केला की घोटाळे होतात. कसे? 

एक्स (भूतपूर्व ट्विटर) वर 'जेम्स ऑफ बॉलिवूड' नावाचं एक हॅन्डल आहे. हिंदी सिनेसृष्टी, ज्याला बॉलिवूड असं म्हणतात, तिथे ४०-५० च्या काळापासून हिंदू तितुका वाईट, हिंदू चालीरीती तितुक्या वाईट, त्यांची कितीही खिल्ली उडवा पण एक प्रेमळ रहीम चाचा, माय सन वगैरे म्हणणारा पाद्री प्रेमळच असणार याची जंत्री मांडलेली असते. बहुतांश खरी असते. पण त्याच हँडलच्या निर्माते-चालक संजीव नेवर यांनी एका मुलाखतीत एका गोष्टीचा अर्थाचा अनर्थ केला आणि घोटाळा केला. 

त्यांनी लता मंगेशकर यांच्या संदर्भातला एक दाखला दिला, की सुरुवातीच्या काळात दिलीप कुमार यांनी लता मंगेशकर यांना उद्देशून एक टोमणावजा वक्तव्य केले की, तुमच्या उर्दूच्या उच्चारात मराठीपणा दिसतो. तर लता मंगेशकर यांनी दीड वर्षे उर्दूची शिकवणी लावून आपले उर्दू उच्चार घोटून घेतले. इतके की कोणाला शंकाही येऊ नये.  त्यावर या नेवर यांचं म्हणणं असं की लता मंगेशकर यांना उर्दू वगैरे शिकण्याची काय गरज होती? आणि त्यांनी ठणकावून सांगण्याची गरज होती की, 'हो, आहे मी मराठी. मग माझ्या उच्चारात मराठीपण येणारच. काय करायचं ते करा.. ' का हो? 

हे असं तिरकं डोकं का चालतं? आणि लता मंगेशकर यांना अक्कल शिकवणारे हे कोण? लता मंगेशकर या साक्षात सरस्वतीच्या संगीत, उच्चार बाबतीत बोलण्याची आपली क्षमता नाही. शिकवणं तर लांबच राहिलं. तसेच त्यांना धर्म विचार यांबद्दलही काही शिकवण्याची, त्याबद्दल बोलण्याची आपली क्षमता नाही. स्वातंत्र्यवीर सावरकरांना आदर्श मानणारे ते कुटुंब आहे. 

लता मंगेशकर यांनी उर्दू शिकण्याचे कष्ट घेतले. आणि तत्कालीन उर्दू शायरांचे प्राबल्य असणाऱ्या सिनेसंगीत सृष्टीत अनेक दशके आपले अधिराज्य गाजवले. उर्दू सोबतच हिंदी, अवधी, ब्रज, आणि भारतातील यच्चयावत भाषांमध्ये त्यानीं गाणी गायली. त्या प्रत्येक भाषेचा पोत, अंगभूत लय समजून, उच्चार स्पष्ट-शुद्ध राखत गायल्या. आपल्या मराठीत तर गायल्याच शिवाय संगीत दिग्दर्शनही केलं. त्या सृष्टीत त्या अनभिषिक्त सम्राज्ञी प्रमाणे वावरल्या. तितक्याच सन्मानाने भारतरत्न होऊन काहीशा निवृत्तही झाल्या. या सगळ्यात त्यांचा अंगभूत मराठीपणा नाही सुटला. त्यांनी सुटू नाही दिला. 

शिरीष कणेकर यांनी एक प्रसंग सांगितला आहे. लता मंगेशकर काणेकरांशी बोलताना एकदा म्हणाल्या होत्या, 'नव्या नट्यांमधे ही माधुरी माझ्याशी हिंदीत का बोलते? आता घरी गेल्यावर मी माईला, क्यों माई कैसी हो, वगैरे म्हणाले तर कसं वाटेल ते?' एक सरळ वाक्य, एक बिनतोड युक्तिवाद. 

त्यांनी आपलं मराठीपण दृढ राखत इतर भाषांवर प्रभुत्व मिळवत त्रिखंड गाजवला. आम्ही आजवर लता मंगेशकर यांच्या व्यक्तिमत्वामधून, कर्तृत्वामधून हाच अर्थ काढला. त्यामुळे अनर्थ नाही झाला, घोटाळा नाही झाला.  

मऱ्हाटीची बोलू कौतुके ते हेच. 

शिरीष कणेकर यांच्याच साक्षीने दुसरा प्रसंग. कणेकर नाना पाटेकर यांच्या घरी बसले होते. हिंदीतल्या एका निर्मात्याचा नानांना फोन आला. चित्रपटाच्या मानधना संबंधी बोलणी सुरु होती. नानांनी एक मोठा आकडा सांगितला. आणि घासाघीस करत एकेक दिवस उशीर करत राहिलास तर दिवसागणिक आकडा वाढत जाईल अशी गर्भित धमकीही दिली. कणेकर म्हणतात मीच जागच्या जागी संकोचलो, नानाला जरा सबुरीचा सल्ला देऊ लागलो तर, नाना म्हणे, जातात कुठे येतील बरोबर. तो आणि इतर अनेक निर्माते आले, नानांनी सांगितली ती रक्कम गुमान दिली आणि नाना हिंदी सिनेसृष्टीत सुपरस्टार झाले. कणेकरांनी या प्रसंगाचा शेवट, "कर्तृत्ववान मराठी माणसाचा हा आत्मविश्वास मला खूप काही शिकवून गेला." असा केला आहे. 

मऱ्हाटीची बोलू कौतुके ते हेच. 

असे अनेक प्रसंग सांगता येतील. संदर्भ देता येतील. मग पुढचा मुद्दा येतो तो आपण मराठी लोक मराठी बोलत नाही म्हणून रस्त्यावरच्या हातगाडीवर विक्री करणाऱ्या, रहिवासी सोसायटी मध्ये मराठी बोलत नाही म्हणून दमदाटी, मारहाण या संकुचित पातळीवर का आलो? मुंबईत अशा प्रसंगांचे प्रमाण जास्त आहे. 

मुंबई मुळातच एक Cosmopolitan शहर आहे. तिथे गिरगावातील मराठी माणूस अंबरनाथ-बदलापूर-वसई-विरार-डोंबिवली कडे कसा आणि का फेकला गेला याची कर्मकहाणी सर्वांना ज्ञात आहे. या मराठी माणसाच्या न्याय्य हक्कांसाठी वगैरे लढणाऱ्या संघटनेने हे होत असताना काही फारसे केले नाही हा इतिहास आहे आणि वर्तमान तर अधिक भेदक आहे. 

मराठी बोलत नाही म्हणून बँकेच्या कर्मचाऱ्याला मारहाण, फेरीवाल्यांना मारहाण आणि हयात मुंबईत घालून मराठीचा म देखील ठाऊक नसणाऱ्या जावेद अख्तर, अमिताभ बच्चन आणि तमाम मांदियाळीला पायघड्या हा दुटप्पीपणा आता वर्तमानात अधिकच ठळकपणे दिसून येत आला. मराठी भाषेच्या संवर्धनासाठी कार्य काय? नन्नाचा पाढा. मराठी माणूस उद्योजक व्हावा अधिक पुढे जावा म्हणून कार्य काय? वडापावच्या गाड्या आणि तत्सम कामे. मराठी माणसाला नोकरी नाही मिळाली तर विमानतळ धावपट्टी उखडून टाकू असल्या विध्वंसक धमक्या. आणि वर हे कलासक्त वगैरे म्हणून मिरवणार. 

हे मऱ्हाटीची कौतुके बोलावी? 

नुसतीच विध्वंसक भाषा बोलण्यापलीकडे जे खरोखर कार्य करतात त्यांच्याकडे आपलं कितपत लक्ष असतं? 

मराठी भाषेची महती, मराठी भाषा ही भव्य, दिव्य आहे हे ठणकावून सांगणारे कौशल इनामदार यांचे मराठी अभिमान गीत असे अनेक प्रकल्प झाले आहेत, होत आहेत. 

मराठी चित्रपटांना स्क्रीन मिळत नाहीत म्हणून नेहमीचा कांगावा असतो. मराठी प्रेक्षक म्हणजे निर्बुद्ध पब्लिक आहे हे गृहीत धरून त्यांना उपदेशाचे डोस पाजणारे चित्रपट करायचे, मराठी मनोरंजन वाहिन्यांवर चालणाऱ्या भंगार-टुकार-वाह्यात मालिकांचे कथानक संक्षिप्त करुन ते चित्रपट म्हणून पुढे आणायचे आणि मग आम्हाला स्क्रीन मिळत नाही हो म्हणून टाहो फोडायचे. असं कसं चालणार? शिवराज अष्टक, सैराट-दशावतार (मला स्वतःला हे अजिबात आवडलेले नाहीत) यांना स्क्रीनसाठी टाहो नाही फोडावा लागला तो? आणि, 

मराठी नाटक, मराठी सांगीतिक कार्यक्रम यांना दणदणीत मराठी आणि इतर भाषिक प्रेक्षक आहे. फोक आख्यान चा सांगीतिक थाट तिकीटविक्री सुरु केल्याच्या काही मिनिटात हाऊसफुल्ल होतो. म्हणजे दोष कोणाचा आहे? 

मराठी माणसाला एक न्यूनगंड आलेला आहे. नक्की कशाचा कोण जाणे? साधी राहणी, उच्च विचारसरणी, धट्टीकट्टी गरिबी आणि लुळीपांगळी श्रीमंती वगैरे कुविचार कधी-कसे-का पक्के बसले कोण जाणे? पुल जे 'श्रीमंतीइतकं धट्टकट्ट काही नसतं हे कळेकळेपर्यंत पार लुळेपांगळे होऊन गेले...' म्हणाले ते खोटं नाही. किंवा उद्योजक मंदार भारदे 'का हो, उच्च राहणी आणि उच्च विचारसरणी नाही का अंगिकारता येत?' हा बिनतोड प्रश्न विचारतात. 

मराठी ही अभिजात भाषा आहे. शासकीय मान्यता आता मिळाली इतकेच. पुल जे म्हणतात की ज्याला स्वभाषेवर प्रेम करता आले तोच इतर भाषांवर स्वार होऊ शकतो. लता मंगेशकर यांनी ते सिद्ध करुन दाखवलं आहे. आपण ही संकुचित वृत्ती सोडून द्यावी. न्यूनगंड सोडून द्यावा. योग्य अर्थ घ्यावे. न्यून ते सोडून द्यावे. मराठीपण दृढ राखावे, मऱ्हाटीची कौतुके बोलावी, जग पादाक्रांत करावे हेच बरे. 


Thursday, 13 November 2025

विश्वास कसा ठेवावा?


दिल्लीतील लाल किल्ला परिसरात स्फोट झाला, १२ जण ठार आणि २१ जखमी.

ही बातमी ऐकताना आपण पुन्हा एकदा हादरलो. हा हादरा यावेळी अधिक खोल होता. कारण २०११–१२ नंतर जम्मू-कश्मीरच्या संवेदनशील पट्ट्याशिवाय भारतात मोठ्या साखळी स्फोटांची मालिका जवळजवळ थांबली होती. तुरळक घटना झाल्या, पण एकूणात सुरक्षिततेची भावना निर्माण झाली होती.
“आमचा मुलगा निष्पाप आहे.”
“सरकार खोटे आरोप करते.”
ही सारवासारवी दरवेळी ऐकताना मनात प्रश्न पुन्हा उभा राहतो, विश्वास कसा ठेवावा?

मणिपूरमधील हल्ल्यानंतर म्यानमार सीमापार कारवाई झाली. उरी हल्ल्यानंतर सर्जिकल स्ट्राईक, पुलवामा नंतर बालाकोट, पहलगाव हल्ल्यानंतर ‘ऑपरेशन सिंदूर’ चे तांडव झाले. 

पण त्यांच्यापेक्षा कितीतरी पट अधिक महत्त्वाच्या, आणि क्वचितच चर्चेत येणाऱ्या, म्हणजे गुप्तचर संस्थांच्या शंभरपैकी नव्व्याण्णव यशस्वी कारवाया कटांचे उधळलेले धागे, पकडले गेलेले शस्त्रसाठे, रोखले गेलेले आत्मघातकी हल्ले, आणि वेळेवर अटकसत्रात अडकवलेले दहशतवादी. 

२०१५–१६ मध्ये गुजरातच्या समुद्रात पकडून बुडवलेली संशयास्पद बोट असो, कांडला बंदरावर जप्त झालेले प्रचंड अंमली पदार्थ असो किंवा देशभरात पकडलेले ISIS प्रेरित ‘लोन वुल्फ’ ही सर्व यशस्वी कारवाया शांततेचा पाया बळकट करत राहिल्या. पडद्यामागे गुप्तचर यंत्रणांनी शेकडो कट उधळले, हल्ले रोखले. अनेकांना अटक झाली, शस्त्रसाठे हाती लागले. या सर्व घटनांच्या छोट्या बातम्या झाल्या, चर्चा नाही.

कारण यशस्वी कारवाई मुख्य शीर्षक होत नाही; पण एक अपयश देश हादरवते.

लाल किल्ल्यातील स्फोट हे असेच ‘निसटते अपयश’. १९ ऑक्टोबरपासून जम्मू-कश्मीरसह गुजरात, उत्तर प्रदेश, हरियाणा, तेलंगणा, पुणे अशा ठिकाणी साखळी अटकसत्रे झाली. इंजिनिअर, डॉक्टर, पॅरामेडिक असे सुशिक्षित लोक या जाळ्यात सापडले. प्राथमिक अंदाजानुसार, सर्व साथीदार पकडले गेल्याचे लक्षात आल्यावर डॉ. उमरने आत्मघातकी स्फोट केला.

तपास सुरू आहे; अनेक माहिती पुढे येईल.

अशा वेळी काही माध्यमांचे नेहमीचेच दृश्य पुन्हा दिसले. दहशतवाद्यांच्या कुटुंबीयांच्या मुलाखती.

याचे उत्तर एका वैयक्तिक अनुभवातून देता येईल.

२००४–०५ चा काळ. आम्ही परभणीत राहत होतो. नांदेडमध्ये आमच्या नव्या घराचे बांधकाम सुरू होते. माझा मामा अभियंता असल्यामुळे कंत्राटदार, मिस्त्री हे त्याच्या ओळखीतील.

एका कामानिमित्त मी नांदेडला गेलो होतो आणि परतताना बांधकामाचे साहित्य आणणाऱ्या ट्रकमध्येच यायचे ठरले. परभणीत मला घ्यायला येणारी व्यक्ती उशिरा पोचली, त्यामुळे मी त्या कंत्राटदार-मिस्त्रींच्या घरी थांबलो.

घर अगदी सामान्य. टीव्ही, सीडी प्लेअर, आणि सीडींचा गठ्ठा. मी कंटाळू नये म्हणून त्यांनी टीव्हीवर एक सिनेमा लावला.

तो सिनेमा पाकिस्तानी होता.

प्रश्न तिथून सुरू झाले. 

त्या काळात परकीय सिनेमाचा अर्थ, हॉलीवूड, किंवा ब्रूस ली-जॅकी चॅन.

मग प्रश्न निर्माण झाला, पाकिस्तानी सिनेमे? ना ते काही विशेष लोकप्रिय, ना ते जागतिक दर्जाचे. परभणीसारख्या शहरातील एक साधारण कंत्राटदार-मिस्त्रीच्या घरात पाकिस्तानी सिनेमांच्या अनधिकृत सीडींचा गठ्ठा का?

  • इतकी आवड?

  • कोणता सांस्कृतिक प्रभाव?

  • कुठली सामाजिक ओढ?

  • की अजून काही?

तेव्हा इंटरनेट नव्हते, युट्यूब नव्हता. तरीही त्या "सीडी" घरोघरी कशा? आणि त्या का हव्या असायच्या? हे काही तात्काळ तर्क लावण्यासारखे साधे प्रकरण नव्हते. हा प्रश्न तेव्हाच मनात पेरला गेला.

जेव्हा एखादा दहशतवादी पकडला जातो तेव्हा कुटुंबीय "तो निरपराध आहे" असे सांगतात. शेजारी त्याला ‘चांगला मुलगा’ म्हणतात. पण एखाद्या समाजात आतून काय पाहिले जाते, काय ऐकले जाते, कोणते प्रभाव आणि कथनं प्रसारित होतात, हे बाहेरच्यांना दिसत नाही.

कधी कधी "आम्ही ८०० वर्षे राज्य केले" अशा मानसिकतेची सावली अजूनही काहींच्या अवचेतनात दिसून येते. आणि त्यामुळेच प्रश्न उरतो, 

विश्वास कसा ठेवावा?

दहशतवादाच्या विरोधातील युद्ध केवळ सीमेवर नाही तर ते घरोघरी लढायचे आहे. सुरक्षा यंत्रणा हल्ले रोखू शकतात. पण संशय, भीती, आणि अविश्वास यांचं निराकरण 'त्या' समाजालाच करावे लागणार आहे. तोवर हा प्रश्न कायम राहणार आहे, 

विश्वास कसा ठेवावा? 

Tuesday, 19 August 2025

Freight Equalization Policy

"A forgotten policy that sowed the seeds of regional economic disparity and laid the foundation for future social and political identities."

“So, despite having mineral resources and fertile land, Bihar, and now Jharkhand, too, could not make the desired progress”

The late former President Pranab Mukherjee made this statement during a program held in Bihar in 2017.

Western and southern India flourished on the strength of the resources of eastern and central India. A Member of Parliament from eastern India presented this fact from independent India’s economic history in somewhat needlessly aggressive language, which sparked controversy.

But this naturally raises the question: How and why did this happen? In ancient and medieval times, the most prosperous kingdoms and empires were located in this very region. While it is not relevant here to delve deep into that distant past, one must note that the economic decline of eastern India began under British rule, and the Freight Equalization Policy put the final nail in the coffin.

The Indian National Congress adopted the vision of a socialistic pattern of society. Accordingly, it established the Planning Commission, and devised a framework of Five-Year Plans to achieve developmental goals.

The First Five-Year Plan focused on agriculture, while the Second Plan emphasized industrial development. Its preamble clearly stated the objective: "To advance national economic development and improve living standards through balanced and coordinated growth of agriculture and industry across all regions."

In 1950, India had only two steel plants — one in Jamshedpur (owned by the Tatas) and another in Bengal. According to the research paper titled "Manufacturing Underdevelopment: India's Freight Equalization Scheme and its Long-Run Effects of Distortion on Geography of Production" by John Firth and Ernst Liu, Bihar (then undivided) accounted for 92% of national steel production and 48% of total industrial output.

Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru was deeply influenced by Fabian socialism and the Soviet economic model. Against this ideological backdrop, Nehru’s government considered eastern India’s natural advantage in industrial development unjust in a broader national context.

It was from this thinking that the Freight Equalization Policy was born, a policy that sowed the seeds of regional economic disparity, and laid the foundation for future social and political identities.

The Freight Equalization Policy was introduced in 1952 by Pandit Nehru’s government. The core provision of this policy was based on the fact that mineral resources, especially coal, iron ore, bauxite, and aluminum, were heavily concentrated in eastern and central India.

To ensure uniform industrial development across the country, the policy stipulated that raw materials (i.e., mineral resources) should be made available at the same price regardless of the location of the factory.

To achieve this, the government subsidized the freight costs, ensuring that industries set up in any region of India could access these minerals at rates comparable to those in the mineral-rich areas.

Against this backdrop, it becomes essential to examine the economic decline of eastern India, which began during the British colonial period. The British launched their imperial ambitions through Bengal, and once they gained control, they introduced the Permanent Settlement system of land revenue in the region.

At the same time, to ensure a steady and reliable supply of raw materials needed for Britain’s industrial revolution, they deliberately altered the agricultural pattern. They enforced the cultivation of indigo and other cash crops, often at the cost of food security.

In parallel, they imposed exorbitant taxes on Indian-made textiles and other goods, effectively crushing the unorganized cottage industries.

During this period, two major global developments also transformed the landscape of international trade and industry.

The first major event was the opening of the Suez Canal. This drastically simplified and accelerated maritime transport between India and Europe.

Earlier, ships had to take the long sea route around the Cape of Good Hope, which meant that Mumbai and Kolkata ports were at roughly equal distance from Europe. With the Suez Canal in operation, Mumbai became significantly closer and more accessible from Europe in both distance and travel time.

The second major event was the American Civil War, which disrupted the steady supply of cotton to Britain’s textile industry. Vidarbha (then part of the Central Provinces) and Gujarat stepped in to fill this gap in cotton supply.

To facilitate this shift, the railway network began to expand towards Mumbai, connecting the cotton-producing hinterlands to the port.

In western and southern India, the Ryotwari system of land revenue remained in place. Under this system, individuals or families held direct ownership of agricultural land, making landholding a central element of rural life.

In contrast, the Permanent Settlement system in eastern India entrenched the zamindari (landlord) model, where absentee landlords held large estates. This led to increasing exploitation of the actual tillers of the soil — the peasants.

While zamindars owning thousands of acres lived lavishly in Kolkata, indulging in art and literature, the rural regions and farmers continued to suffer under economic distress.

With a few exceptions, zamindars and princely estate holders did not prioritize entrepreneurship or developmental initiatives.

In western and southern India, princely states like Baroda, Kolhapur, Mysore, and Aundh had visionary rulers who prioritized modernization and industrial

development. They launched several progressive projects focused on these goals.

In addition, the cooperative movement in Gujarat and Maharashtra brought new energy to rural areas. People in these regions already had relatively higher purchasing power, which only continued to grow.

Against this backdrop, post-independence states like Bihar, Bengal, Odisha, and Madhya Pradesh had abundant mineral wealth, an industrial base in Jamshedpur, and fertile agricultural land.

Then came the Freight Equalization Policy; the government subsidized freight costs for raw materials like minerals, ensuring they could be transported anywhere in India at the same price.

At the same time, Mumbai and Chennai (then Madras) were, and still remain, the most efficient ports for exports (with Kandla and several ports in Kerala later joining this network).

The state governments in western and southern India also offered land at concessional rates, along with other industry-friendly incentives.

A strong educational foundation ensured the availability of skilled human resources.

As a result, entrepreneurs no longer had any compelling reason or incentive to set up industries in mineral-rich regions. Instead, they naturally gravitated toward areas that combined accessibility, infrastructure, and policy support, mostly in the west and south.

Western and southern India witnessed the emergence of industries such as automobile manufacturing, engineering, and cement production.

There is a biological truth that shrubs wither under the shade of a large tree, but in the industrial world, this metaphor applies in exactly the opposite way. Under the canopy of a large industrial hub, hundreds of smaller industries take root and thrive.

That is precisely what happened in Pune, Coimbatore, Chennai, Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad), Mumbai, Gujarat, Bengaluru, and Hyderabad. With industrial development, these cities and states rapidly became increasingly prosperous.

In stark contrast, the eastern and central Indian states, which supplied the raw materials, continued to lag behind in development, becoming progressively more backward.

By the 1970s and 1980s, prominent individuals from eastern states began to recognize the negative consequences of the Freight Equalization Policy.

They started raising their voices demanding a fair share of mineral royalties for their states. (Although not directly related to this policy, the issue of crude oil, the Narengi pumping station, and Assam’s lack of benefit from it was also one of the major triggers behind the Assam Movement in the 1980s.)

Taking note of growing concerns, the government constituted a ministerial committee in 1977. In its report, the committee observed that the subsidies provided under the policy were minimal in monetary value.

While the subsidy amount was small in absolute terms, the sheer volume of goods transported under the scheme resulted in substantial relief for industries.

In 1991, the government introduced an upper cap on the subsidy, but this measure had little impact in addressing the core problem.

Against this backdrop, just consider how deadly the combination of the License-Permit Raj and the Freight Equalization Policy truly was.

The noble objective was equitable distribution of wealth. There was also a strong insistence that this wealth should be generated primarily through the public sector. At the same time, the state intended to prevent the creation of monopolies or private dominance.

In essence, the system discouraged the generation of wealth, but still focused on its distribution. As a result, by 1991, what we achieved was an equitable distribution of poverty.

Western and southern India surged ahead in terms of economic progress. With growing economic prosperity, the social structure gradually evolved as well. The spread and acceptance of education expanded rapidly alongside this prosperity, leading naturally to greater awareness and population control.

The population growth rates in these states fell below the replacement rate. At the same time, more and more young people began to migrate abroad and settle there permanently.

Meanwhile, in contrast, eastern and central India saw increasing waves of migration, as large numbers of people moved in search of employment opportunities.

Article 280 of the Constitution provides for the Finance Commission. The primary function of the Finance Commission is to determine how the total revenue of India should be distributed among the various states. This distribution is based on criteria such as the population of the states, their economic and social development, and the equitable distribution of economic growth within the states.



Due to the Freight Equalization Policy and certain earlier policies, the states in North, East, and North-Eastern India lagged behind in the path of development. Because of their lower purchasing power, the collection of consumption-based indirect taxes in these states is also lower. As a result, based on the recommendations of the Finance Commission, these states receive a larger share of the total collected taxes.

For example, suppose ₹100 is contributed by Maharashtra to the national tax collection. Out of that, only ₹7 comes back to Maharashtra. In contrast, Jharkhand receives ₹303, Odisha ₹187, and Chhattisgarh ₹282 for every ₹100 they contribute.

So, what about the revenue and income of states like Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Gujarat, and Karnataka? The answer lies in the monthly GST collection data published by the government. GST is a consumption-based indirect tax, of which half is directly credited to the state’s treasury.

These states have strong internal revenue sources due to factors such as: robust industrial and business activity, a wealthy population, a large and financially capable middle class, and significant commercial transactions.

In the case of Maharashtra, 67% of its total revenue comes from internal sources within the state.

However, even after the onset of economic reforms and the withdrawal of the Freight Equalization Policy in 1993, former Lok Sabha Speaker Somnath Chatterjee made a noteworthy statement regarding the states of East and Central India:

"The losses caused by the Freight Equalization Policy and the dismantling of the license-permit regime through economic reforms can never truly be compensated..."

In a way, the revenue distribution recommended by the Finance Commission acts as compensation for the damage caused to those states due to the Freight Equalization Policy.

Against this entire backdrop, we must take into account the regional identities of Marathi, Kannada, and Tamil cultures. There is a growing sentiment that “Have we committed a crime by exercising population control and achieving economic development?”

Every Indian citizen has a constitutional right to reside, engage in trade, conduct business, and seek employment in any part of India. However, it is essential that this right is not misused or turned into a form of dominance.

Our future path must be shaped with this sensitivity in mind. Otherwise, we risk creating divisions in Indian society where none exist, or widening those that already do, thereby unintentionally empowering oppositional forces both within and outside India.

It is our duty to preserve India’s unity and integrity, and we shall continue to uphold that responsibility. But in doing so, we must also study the cracks that exist, and take timely action to bridge them. This article is a humble attempt in that direction.

Artha and the Civilisation: What Really Drives the Indian Economy

  Any system rests on two principal components. One is the driving force behind the system's construction, and the other is the guiding ...