Wednesday, 2 February 2022

Swayampurna Goa


 "Goa means nature & tourism, but today it also means a new model of development and a reflection of collective efforts. Goa means solidarity for development from Panchayat to Administration." 

Hon'ble Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi praised the state of Goa with these words while interacting with the changemakers in the state under a unique initiative of the state government. The new, innovative initiative of the Govt of Goa is in line with the Atmanirbhar Bharat Abhiyan by Prime Minister Modi. The Govt believes that the State Govt's initiative is its contribution to the grand Abhiyan of Atmanirbhar Bharat aimed at building New India. The unique and innovative initiative is Swayampurna Goa. 

The Swayampurna Goa initiative was launched on 1st October 2020 by Chief Minister Dr. Pramod Sawant. At the launch of the initiative Chief Minister stated, "Every village Panchayat needs to adopt various sustainable measures to gain economic empowerment. The initiative is the endeavor of Govt. of Goa to transform Goa into an ideal State, and the Govt. has embarked upon the theme 'Vision 2020-2025 to initiate efforts to revamp state administration & make it deliver better and transparent government to people.' 

The Program includes the 10 Point program to ensure 

1: Tap Water for All

2: Electricity for All

3:Shelter (Home) for all

4: Sanitation for All

5: Krishi Card, PM Kisan, Kisan Credit Card, Health Card for All, 

6: Eligible Aid for Divyangas

7: Health Security for All

8: Social Security for All - Deen Dayal Samajik Surakhsa Yojana

9: Financial Security for All - Bank A/C, PM Jeevan Jyoti Bima, PM Suraksha Bima Yojana

10: Senior Citizen Card

Skill mapping of population, Resource identification of villages to ensure that every village becomes self-sustainable. Focus on eradication of poverty with the participation of locals. The study for Economic Revival of for village panchayat was undertaken by the Directorate of Higher Education and Goa Institute of Public Administration and Rural Development. Individual report of 191 Village panchayats were prepared and released by Chief Minister. 

To implement the program the Govt. of Goa came up with another unique approach of governance with the concept of 'Swayampurna Mitra' to be appointed at village and municipality level. Accordingly, Swayampurna Mitras for 191 Gram Panchayats and 14 Municipalities in the state were appointed. The Swayampurna Mitras are the State Govt. employees. They have not been offered any special concessions, special allowances for the program. Nodal officers were appointed at Taluka level, i.e. 12 nodal officers. 

The Swayampurna Mitras were tasked to coordinate with Sarpanch, Municipal Chairman, Panchayat  Members, Councilors, Panchayat Secretaries. They were asked to visit their respective village, Municipality on holidays. So that benefits of welfare schemes implemented by the State, and Centrally Sponsored schemes reach the needy, and deserving people. Ensuring the effective implementation of the schemes. 

The Swayampurna Mitras were also tasked to identify the need and requirements of village-specific initiatives, projects for the betterment of the village, employment generation, entrepreneurship development, etc. Grant of Rs.50 Lakhs to be given for innovative projects under Swayampurna Goa. Projects such as Panchayat Ghar, Community hall, Crematorium, and other initiatives certified by the Swayampurna Mitras. 

The Swayampurna Mitras did visit their respective villages o holidays. Took notes on issues of the villagers. Worked to resolve the issues under the 10 point program rapidly. The 10 point program implementation turned out to be a program of taking the government to the doorstep of the people. However, the really challenging and innovative task were to identify and implement unique projects for self-reliant villages, municipalities. Following are the select success stories of unique, innovative projects implemented under Swayampurna Goa. 

Assonora village in Bardez taluka in North Goa district. The village panchayat, Swayampurna Mitra, Under Women Development Program of the Govt., coordinated with the Rotary Club of Mapusa. The Rotary Club donated 21 sewing machines to the women for self-sustenance, entrepreneurship development at the village level. The state faced the wrath of Tauktae Cyclone and unprecedented floods. To diversify and make the disaster management system more inclusive, 38 women were trained as 'Apada Nari' with the basics of disaster relief, First Aid, etc. 

The region is the beneficiary of the Tilari canal for water supply for irrigation, drinking water. However, the canal project has caused flooding in the fields of many farmers. The farmers came together, identified an alternative farmland, with the help of Swayampurna Mitra started farming on the said land. They took harvest of Tomatoes, Chillies, Cucumbers, and Brinjals. On one hand, the villagers came together for alternative source of livelihood, while on the other hand, the Swayampurna Mitra took the issue of flooding of fields to the State Water Resources Department.  

Kirlapal Dabhal in Dharbandora taluka,North Goa. The region has a substantial tribal population. The Swayampurna Mitra took initiative under the 'Adivasi Vikas Yojana' of the Goa Tribal Welfare Department and build a community hall for the village. The Mitra coordinated a meeting between the villagers of Karmane affected by irregular water release in the canal and the Water Resource Department and resolved the issue with chalking down the specific pattern for the water release and sharing pattern. 

4 youth from Rumbrem and Bandoli villages took up a property to develop Eco-Tourism project. The Swayampurna Mitra supported and encouraged the venture with clearances and other procedures. The project is based on the 'Tribal Village Life' concept. A local Self Help Group prepares and provides food for the tourists. The project undertakes organic farming and sell those products at the site. This project has helped 15 families go Swayampurna. 

Morpirla Village, Qupem, South Goa District. 72 students from the Tribal community took Computer training under the 'Short Term Professional Training Scheme' for tribal youth of the State Tribal Welfare Department. It has helped them to seek jobs, start their business venture to become Swayampurna.

Surla, Bicholim, North Goa. The villagers with the support of Swayampurna Mitras identified a barren land of 50,000 sq.m. not cultivated for more than 12 years. 40 farmers took initiative and collectively brought it under cultivation under community farming. The project was implemented with the support of the 'Atal Gram Development Agency'  

These are a few of the many unique and innovative projects taken under the Swayampurna Goa scheme with coordination of Swayampurna Mitras, Villagers, Sarpanch, Panchayat members, Municipality chairman, councilors, etc. A system of 'Swayampurna Parikshak' was set for the monitoring and coordination of Swayampurna Mitras. Moreover, to review the projects, initiatives, works of Swayampurna Mitra, Chief Minister Dr. Pramod Sawant came up with another innovative program to take the Govt. to the Doorstep of the people i.e. 'Sarkar Tumchya Dari' (literally meaning Govt. at Your Doorstep) 


The Sarkar Tumchya Dari program was a unique program where on a given day, all the Govt. machinery from District Collector to various department heads, went to the village for a day. Where CM interacted with the Swayampurna Mitras, Sarpanches, Panchayat Members, etc. took a review of the projects undergoing, listened to the issues raised, and directed the authorities to resolve those. The Sarkar Tumchya Dari served multiple purposes. The common people got the knowledge of the available schemes for their benefit. They got to know whom to be approached for what sort of work to be done. And most importantly, it assured the people that this is the Govt. that works, reach to the last mile. 

The Prime Minister took note of the unique and innovative approach of governance. On 23rd October 2021 PM virtually interacted with the Swayampurna Mitra, Sarpanch, Beneficiaries of the Swayampurna Goa program. Prime Minister praised the program saying, "State means a new model of development and a reflection of collective efforts. when people get the support of the Govt. and hard work of the people, how change comes, self-confidence comes, we all experienced during our discussion with beneficiaries." 

Prime Minister Interacted with Swayampurna Mitras, Sarpanchas


The Swayampurna Goa is not just limited to the 10 Point program, innovative projects for the development and making villages Swayampurna. The State Govt. has been working towards formulating policies towards making the state Swayampurna in true sense. The best tourist destination in India is dependent upon neighboring states for meat, milk, food grains, many other things. The Govt. has formulated the Start-Up policy that creates a robust environment for Start-Ups aimed at Swayampurna Goa. 

The Govt. has taken up a project to build dairy clusters and dairy estates. It is encouraging youth for dairy farming. Farmers are being supported for the enhancement of average milk production. Many villages have taken up projects for dairy farming and distribution with the support of Swayampurna Mitras. Govt. has formulated the 'Goa Marine Culture Policy 2020' for the development of the Fisheries sector. Notification of minimum legal size, conservation of fishing resources, leasing of platform for drying of fish has been done. The Fisheries department conducted more than 110 programs with 3948 participants. With the aim of Swayampurna Goa. 

Earlier there were very limited facilities of Multi-Specialty Hospitals. The patients had to be shifted to Bangalore or Mumbai for treatments of critical ailments. The Govt of Goa supported, encouraged private hospitals to enhance their capacity and robustness. The State Govt. enhanced the capacities, established specialty facilities at the District Hospitals, Health centers in Goa. The COVID-19 pandemic turned out to be a tough test. But the Govt. turned the crisis into an opportunity to enhance the resources and capacities. Established the Oxygen generation plants under the PM-CARES. With all the efforts, the state on the path of Swayampurna Goa. 

Goa is gearing up with the implementation of a New Education Policy, with Coding and Robotics Education in Schools scheme, institutions like National Forensic Science University are in Goa. The Introduction of new, entrepreneurship development-oriented courses aimed the goal of Swayampurna Goa. The Govt. is committed to the Swayampurna Goa in every sector. Its aim is not limited to just self-reliance but also contributing to the nationwide ambitious program of Atmanirbhar Bharat. 

The last 10 years were of development of the state, The next 5 years are committed to the prosperity of the state by the Bharatiya Janata Party. With rapid infrastructure development, future oriented policies, adoption of digital governance, unique initiatives the state of Goa shall achieve the goad of Swayampurna Goa. 

Published: Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha Magazine February Edition. 

Wednesday, 12 January 2022

कुमार गंधर्व


  कुमारच्या चेहऱ्यावर आजाराचे कुठलेच लक्षण नव्हते. पाच वर्षापूर्वीच्याच कानांना 'आता अवधारिजो जी' असे जरासे बजावून सांगणारा तोच, तसाच षड्ज लागला आणि त्यापूर्वी कोणीही न ऐकलेल्या एका रागातल्या चिजेचा अद्भुत मुखडा कानी पडला, "मारुजी भूलो ना म्हाने". अस्ताई म्हटल्यावर पुन्हा चिजेच्या तोंडाकडे येताना मारुजीमधल्या 'जी'वर कुमार कोमल रिषभावर दोनच सेकंद असेल पण अशा ताकदीने ठेहरला की त्या कोमल रिषभाचा तीर मैफिलीला आरपार भेदून गेला. त्या रिषभाची जखम आजही माझ्या मनात ओलीच आहे. कुमारने मग त्या रागाचे नाव सांगितले, 'सोहनीभटियार' आणि म्हणाला, "गेल्या काही वर्षात असे काही नवे राग आणि नव्या चिजा झाल्या आहेत." पु.ल. नावाच्या शब्दप्रभूने 'मंगल दिन आज' या गुण गाईन आवडी मधील व्यक्तिचित्रात पंडित कुमार गंधर्व या संगीतातील अलौकिक चमत्काराचे असे वर्णन केले आहे. 

पुल ज्याप्रमाणे त्या नव्या रागातील कोमल रिषभाचा तीर मैफिलीला आरपार भेदून गेला असे वर्णन करतात, तो कोमल रिषभ लागला, म्हणजे काय झालं हे नीट सविस्तर समजावून सांगितल्याशिवाय काही मला कळणार नाही. पण एक गोष्ट नक्की की कुमार गंधर्वांचं गाणं काळजाला भिडतं. एक विलक्षण भावना मनात दाटते. ती भावना वर्णनातीत असते. आजतागायत ती तशीच आहे. त्यामुळेच कुमार गंधर्व या महापुरुषाबद्दल आपण भक्तिभाव यापलीकडे दुसऱ्या भावनेने पाहू शकत नाही. चिकित्सा वगैरे फार लांब राहिली. त्यांच्या कार्याचे आकलन जरी झाले तरी भरून पावलो. 

पुलंची त्या 'सोहनीभटियार' शी पहिली ओळख साक्षात कुमार गंधर्वांनी करुन दिली. माझी पहिली ओळख झाली राहुल देशपांडे यांच्या 'कुमार राग विलास' या कार्यक्रमात. इतर शास्त्रीय गायक गातात, किंवा स्वतः राहुल देशपांडेच गातात त्यापेक्षा हे वेगळं आहे. या मांडणीत एक विलक्षण आर्तता आहे. काळजात चलबिचल करणारी आर्तता आहे. ती सुरवात मनावर गारुड करणारी आहे. त्या दिवशी मनात ते "मारुजी भूलो ना म्हाने... अब घर तुम बिन राता डर लागे म्हाने" या शब्दांनी मनात विलक्षण खळबळ माजवली. त्याच धुंदीत एक निश्चय झाला की, साक्षात त्या गंधर्वांची गायकी ऐकली पाहिजे. 

आता श्रवण-दृश्यभक्ती साठी सर्वात मोठा आसरा म्हणजे युट्युब. त्या तंत्रज्ञानाच्या आश्रयाला गेलो. त्यानी निराश केलं नाही. कुमार गंधर्वांच्या गायनाचं भांडार खुलं झालं. सुरुवात अर्थातच सोहनीभटियार ने केली. पुन्हा तोच अनुभव. एकदा ऐकून समाधान होईना. त्या दिवशी तेवढा एकच राग किती वेळा ऐकला असेल माहिती नाही. युट्युब ही एक अशी अजब गुहा आहे की एकदा आत गेलात की जातच राहता. हे ऐकत असतानाच शेजारी रेकमेंडेशन मध्ये बिहाग होता. बिहाग हा मुळात आवडत्या रागांपैकी एक आहे. कुमार गंधर्व रचित बिहाग रागातील ती "मोरा मन.." बंदीश अशीच वेगळ्या जगात घेऊन जाते. एकामागून एक राग ऐकत गेलो. आणि एक गोष्ट परत ठसठशीतपणे जाणवली. ती म्हणजे प्रचलित शास्त्रीय संगीत गायकीपेक्षा ही गायकी काहीशी वेगळी आहे. आणि हेही तेवढ्याच तीव्रतेने जाणवलं की केवळ वगेळेपणाच्या अट्टाहासापायी हे केलेलं नाही. तर विचारपूर्वक झालेली ही कृती आहे. 


कुमार गंधर्वांचा आणखी एक महत्वपूर्ण आविष्कार म्हणजे भजन. त्यात सगुण-निर्गुण भजन सर्व आले. कुमारांच्या आवाजात जेव्हा 'उड जायेगा हंस अकेला, जग दर्शन का मेला' हे कबीराचे शब्द येतात, तेव्हा त्या शब्दांतली भावना कुमार गंधर्वांपेक्षा थेट, काळजाला भिडेल अशी दुसरी कोणी मांडू शकणार नाही अशी खात्रीच पटते. कबीर, मीरा, तुलसीदासांच्या रचनांना कुमारांनी चढवलेला स्वरसाज असो की माळवी लोकगीते, माळवी लोकगीतांच्या धून हाती धरून नव्याने रचलेले राग असो हा गंधर्व क्षणोक्षणी अचंबित करत राहतो. शास्त्रीय संगीताचं आणि एकूणच संगीताचं सखोल चिंतन करणारा, ते पचवणारा आणि त्यातून नवनिर्मिती करणारा हा अवलिया कलावंत होता. 

कुमार गंधर्वांचं गाणं ऐन बहरात येत असताना त्यांना दुर्धर आजाराने गाठलं. अनेक वर्ष हा दैवी आवाज शांत होता. पण त्या शांततेच्या काळात हा अवलिया चिंतन करत होता. इतर अनेक आवाज, धून डोक्यात साठवीत होता. ते आजारपण जणू पुढल्या क्रांतिकारी नवनिमिर्तीसाठीच्या शांततेचा काळ ठरला. संगीतातला नवा विचार, नवी मांडणी अधिकाधिक लोकांपर्यंत पोचवण्यासाठी कार्यरत असणारा हा कलावंत होता. तो विचार त्यांनी 'अनूप राग विलास' या श्रेष्ठ ग्रंथात मांडला आहे. तो विचार, मांडणीतली विविधता, नवेपणा अनेकांना प्रेरणा देणारा ठरला. वसंतराव देशपांडेंसारखे कुमार गंधर्वांपेक्षा वयाने ज्येष्ठ असणारे गायक त्यांच्याकडून काही शिकण्यासाठी तत्पर असतात. अशा अवलियास पुल, रामूभैया दाते, वसंतराव देशपांडे आणि इतर अनेक क्षेत्रातले असंख्य स्नेही लाभले. आजारपणात साथ देणारे कुटुंबीय, आप्त लाभले. हे प्रेम, स्नेह दुतर्फी होते. पंडित मुकुल शिवपुत्र, कलापिनी कोमकली, सत्यशील देशपांडे आणि असे अनेक शिष्य त्यांनी घडवले. 

 शास्त्रीय संगीताच्या क्षेत्रात क्रांतिकारी नवनिर्मिती करणाऱ्या शिवपुत्रास भावपूर्ण श्रद्धांजली. 



Thursday, 30 September 2021

Democracy At Work part 2

 


Awake, Organize and use all the tools of constitutional democracy for the betterment of society. This is the core ideology to make Democracy Work in remote villages of Jawhar-Mokhada under the Vayam movement. In part 1 (https://shaunak-kulkarni.blogspot.com/2021/09/democracy-at-work-part-1.html) we discussed the core ideas and ideals behind the Vayam movement. Went through some of the initiatives of the movement. 

At the Abhyas Varga, the Vayam movement felicitated the representatives of the village 'Devicha Pada' for carrying out a task by applying all the democratic tools for the betterment of the village. I think this anecdote would be enough to explain, elaborate what Vayam is working for and how Democracy can work. 

The Gram Sabha meetings of Devicha Pada village used to be conducted at the 'Paar' (An open place under a huge tree, with temporary platforms.) It was difficult to conduct meetings during monsoon months due to heavy rains, and in summer due to heat. The Gram Sabha decided to build a shade in the main circle of the village. 

A permanent place for the Gram Sabha as well as can be used for other public gatherings. The notice for the meeting was duly issued. The meeting was conducted. The plans were carried out according to the need. The village decided to build it by making maximum use of available resources and funds. The village came together, contributed through 'Shrama Daan' and built the shade. 

One thing needs to be noted here, as I felt it amazing, that while receiving the felicitation the representatives of Devicha Pada village were a little timid. The representative who was asked to say a few words on behalf of the village was quite hesitant at the beginning. 

He spoke for a few minutes after insisting, I must say it was an absolute best example of sharp, crisp articulation. He explained how they conducted the meeting, placed resolution before Sabha to get through, how all the villagers contributed, and thanking Vayam for the guidance. 

I spent a good time discussing issues in the area and Vayam came up with innovative ideas to mitigate those issues with Milind Thatte ji. I had noted down few issues after a little research. 

One of the important issues among them is of malnutrition among children and subsequent health-related issues due to it. According to Milind ji, one of the major reasons behind malnutrition is early marriage and early pregnancies. Of course, the less availability of nutritious food is there. But such lack of nutritious food, early marriages and pregnancies exacerbate the issues. 

There are multiple programs run by the State and Union govt to mitigate the issue. But Milind ji stresses more on consuming the local food, vegetables found naturally in jungles, known as Ran Bhaji (Jungle vegetables). He also states on need for consumption of such vegetables for at least 8-9 months in a year. 

Local people cultivate vegetables in their courtyards for consumption. This cultivation is mainly carried out during the monsoon period and a brief period after the monsoon. when the water availability reduces they move to the staple food of simple Daal-Rice. Buying vegetables from the market at Jawhar and Mokhada is a costly and time-consuming affair. 

To mitigate this issue the 'Vayam' came up with an innovative solution of small farm ponds of size 2.5*2.5*1 meter. The topography of the region does not allow large farm ponds of regular size. Vayam shall provide the plastic film for the pond initially. 

A small pond of such size can be dug by an individual. The concept is run on a pilot basis in some selected areas. These small ponds can be covered with plastic, and other materials easily available at home to reduce evaporation loss. These small ponds either filled with rainwater or recharged with groundwater can provide water for at least the cultivation of vegetables in courtyards, small portions of farmlands. 

The Small Farm Ponds

The locals have the best knowledge of their jungles, forest products. They know Ran Bhajis.

To propagate, make the locals more aware of their source of nutrition the Vayam movement came with the idea of 'Ran Bhaji Mahotsav' where villagers bring various Ran Bhajis. They explain the importance, nutrition value to villagers, visitors from other places, mainly from urban areas. 

I could not attend one of those due to COVID and monsoon rains the Ran Bhaji Mahotsavs are conducted with very limited presence. 

The Vayam movement has taken the next step to preserve, protect and expand the scope of forest resources.

As a pilot project in that direction, Vayam asked 10 villages to send 1 representative to be trained and employed to conduct surveys of jungles, rivers, and other water beds to document forest products. the document can be termed as an informal gazette of forest produce available in the region. 

According to the idea, the Gram Sabhas of 10 villages conducted meetings to decide whom to be sent for the project. The representatives were selected and sent for the project and Gram Sabha decided to keep an eye on their activities regularly. The representatives are paid with a stipend to carry out the task. 

Under this documentation project, the type of forest produce, the time frame of availability, whether they are sold in markets or they are just consumed, the scale of availability is recorded. 

While going through the document under preparation, I discussed the whole idea with a representative. He elaborated the whole process. His one sentence struck me on the background of the schemes initiated by the Union govt under Tribal Affairs Ministry such as the TRIFED, Van Dhan Vikas Karyakram, and the MSP for the Minor Forest Produce. 

He said, with this kind of document we know the costs incurred to gather these forest products, the scale of possible supplies, so we will be able to decide, or at least we will be in a position to negotiate the price with traders, buyers with an upper hand. 

These fascinating conversations placed a great learning experience for me. Every innovative idea, people's participation, and enthusiasm ensured that the Democracy will continue to be at work.. 


मराठवाडा मुक्ती संग्राम



"हा लढा बलिदान करू इच्छिणाऱ्या श्रद्धावान अहिंसकांनी आपल्या बलिदानाने रंगवला असता तर मला आवडले असते! पण अशा बलिदानाची तयारी नसणाऱ्या मंडळींनी भेकडपणे पळून जाणे अगर लाचारी पत्करणे यापेक्षा मी प्रतिकार करणारे लोक श्रेष्ठतर मानतो." 

स्वातंत्र्यलढ्यासाठी अहिंसेच्या तत्वावर आधारित सत्याग्रहाचा पुरस्कार करणाऱ्या महात्मा गांधीजींनी, धार्मिक कट्टरतेच्या आधारावर बहुसंख्य हिंदूंवर अत्याचार करणाऱ्या एका संस्थानात, बहुसंख्य हिंदूंनी त्यांच्या न्याय्य हक्कांसाठी हिंसक मार्गाचाही अवलंब केला तर त्यात काही चूक नाही, हे मान्य केले होते. 

भारताच्या दक्षिण-मध्य भागात, तत्कालीन भारतातील सर्वात मोठे होते हैदराबादचे निजाम संस्थान. त्या संस्थानची लोकसंख्या १.६ कोटी होती. एकूण लोकसंख्येपैकी ८६ टक्के लोक हिंदू असणारे ते एक 'मुस्लिम संस्थान' होते. हैदराबादच्या मुस्लिम संस्थानिकाने धार्मिक आधारावर सर्व रचना केली होती. या रचनेखाली बहुसंख्य असणारी हिंदू किंवा संस्थानच्या अधिकृत नोंदींप्रमाणे गैरमुस्लिम जनता पिचली जात होती. आर्य समाजाच्या कार्यामुळे प्रामुख्याने सामान्य हिंदू जनतेत जागृती होत गेली. ही जागृत होणारी सामान्य जनता आपल्या हक्कांसाठी, एकसंध भारताशी एकजूट होण्यासाठी स्वामी रामानंद तीर्थ, दिगंबरराव बिंदू, बाबासाहेब परांपजे, अनंत भालेराव आणि भाई गोविंददास श्रॉफ या नेत्यांच्या नेतृत्वाखाली लढण्यास एकत्र आली. 

थोर विचारवंत, लेखक आणि हैदराबाद मुक्ती संग्राम आंदोलनातील एक तरुण कार्यकर्ता, नरहर कुरुंदकर यांनी अशा शब्दांत हिंसक आंदोलनाची आवश्यकता विशद केली आहे, 

"हैदराबाद संस्थानात कुठलेही कायद्याचे राज्य नव्हते. शैक्षणिक, सामाजिक, औद्योगिक आणि राजकीयदृष्ट्या मागासलेल्या संस्थानात एक धर्मवेडी राजवट नांदत होती."

सामान्यांचा असामान्य लढा, चर्चां-वाटाघाटींचे अनेक फड आणि शेवटी 'ऑपरेशन पोलो' या नावाने करण्यात आलेली पोलीस कारवाई या सर्वांचा परिपाक म्हणजे, १७ सप्टेंबर, १९४८ रोजी हैदराबाद संस्थान भारतात विलीन झाले. एकसंध भारताच्या निर्मितीतील एक टप्पा पूर्ण झाला. 

संस्थानातील सामान्य जनता एवढ्या मोठ्या प्रमाणावर जागृत आणि लढण्यास उद्युक्त का झाली, हे समजून घेण्यासाठी मुळात 'निजाम' संस्थान म्हणजे काय ते समजून घ्यावे लागेल. 

औरंगजेबाच्या मुघल सैन्यातील एक सरदार मीर कमरुद्दीन, ज्याला चिन किलीच खान (छोटा तलवार बहाद्दर) असे बिरुद मिळाले होते, याने केंद्रीय मुघल सत्तेच्या दुबळेपणाचा लाभ घेत १७२४ मध्ये  दख्खनेत आपल्या स्वतंत्र राजवटीची स्थापना केली. त्याने स्वतःला निजाम-उल-मुल्क असे बिरुद घेतले. वास्तविक निजामांनी मराठ्यांच्या आणि इतर भारतीय सत्तांच्या हातून लढायांमध्ये कायम पराभवांचाच सामना केला. पालखेड (१७२८), भोपाळ (१७३७), उदगीर (१७६०) आणि राक्षसभुवन (१७६३) या काही लढाया सर्वज्ञात आहेत. पण वेळोवेळी अपमानकारक तह स्वीकारत तर काही वेळा मराठ्यांच्यामधील बेबनावाचा लाभ घेत निजामाने आपले राज्य टिकवून ठेवले. अठराव्या शतकाच्या शेवटच्या निजामाने काळात टिपू आणि मराठ्यांपासून संरक्षणासाठी सुरुवातीला फ्रेंच तर नंतर ब्रिटिशांची मदत घेतली. शेवटी १७९५ मध्ये निजामाने ब्रिटिश ईस्ट इंडिया कंपनीसोबत तैनाती फौजेचा करार स्वीकारला. त्यानुसार ब्रिटिश सैन्य हैदराबाद शहर तसेच संस्थानात अनेक ठिकाणी तैनात झाले. 

हैदराबाद संस्थान तीन भाषिक विभागांचे बनलेले होते. त्यातला मराठी भाषिक प्रदेश म्हणजेच आजचा मराठवाडा, कन्नड भाषिक प्रदेश म्हणजेच आजचा हैदराबाद कर्नाटक किंवा कल्याण कर्नाटक प्रदेश तर तेलुगू भाषिक भाग म्हणजेच सामान्यतः आजचे तेलंगण राज्य होय. 

संस्थानाचा एकतृतीयांश भाग जहागिरींचा होता. जहागीरदारांत निजामाच्या सैन्यातील मुस्लिम सरदारांचा समावेश होता. हिंदू जहागीरदारांची संख्या अगदीच नगण्य होती. काही काळ निजामाचे पंतप्रधान असणारे महाराज किशनप्रसाद हे याच जहागीरदारांपैकी होते. सर्वात मोठे जहागीरदार स्वतः निजामच होते. निजामाचे तत्कालीन पंतप्रधान सालारजंग यांनी संस्थानची विभाग, जिल्हे आणि तालुकावार रचना केली. त्यानुसार प्रत्येक जिल्ह्यातील एक तालुका निजामाच्या खासगी खर्चासाठी म्हणून राखून ठेवण्यात आला होता. 

संस्थानातील दुसरा महत्वाचा घटक म्हणजे जमीनदारी. तेलुगू भाषिक प्रदेशात जमीनदार तसेच जमीनदारीखाली असणाऱ्या जमिनीची संख्या जास्त होती. जमीनदारीमध्ये मुस्लिमांची संख्या अधिक होती हे वेगळे नमूद करण्याची खरेतर गरज नाही. 

संस्थानचे सातवे आणि शेवटचे निजाम मीर उस्मान अली बहादूर, यांनी संस्थानची आधुनिक पद्धतीने रचना केली होती. संस्थानची स्वतःची चलनव्यवस्था होती. ब्रिटिश भारतीय रुपया आणि जागतिक चलनांशी त्याचा विनिमय दर निश्चित करण्यात आला होता. संस्थानची स्वतःची रेल्वे व्यवस्था होती. स्वतःची पोस्ट आणि तार यंत्रणा होती. निजामाने 'इंडियन सिव्हिल सर्व्हिस'च्या (ICS) धर्तीवर हैदराबाद सिव्हिल सर्व्हिस (HCS) स्थापन केली होती. जिचा दर्जा ICS च्या तोडीस तोड होता. वस्त्रोद्योग, कोळसा आणि इतर काही खनिजे या क्षेत्रांत उद्योग होते. स्वतःची शिक्षणव्यवस्था होती. पण सर्व जीवनावर मुस्लिम वर्चस्व होते. सर्व राज्यकारभाराची भाषा उर्दू होती. 

संस्थानात 'इत्तेहादुल मुसलमीन' ही जात्यंध संघटना होती. तिचेच सुधारित, अधिक धर्मांध, सशस्त्र स्वरूप म्हणजेच रझाकार. पोलीस कारवाईच्या काळात या सशस्त्र रझाकारांची संख्या दोन लाखांवर होती. रझाकारांनी गावागावात हिंदूंवर अनन्वित अत्याचार केले. ऑगस्ट-सप्टेंबर १९४७ ते सप्टेंबर १९४८ या काळात या अत्याचारांनी कळसाध्याय गाठला होता. हैदराबाद संस्थानच्या विलीनीकरणानंतर भारत सरकारने रझाकारांच्या अत्याचारांवर एक श्वेतपत्रिका प्रसिद्ध केली. त्यात प्रमुख घटना नमूद करण्यात आल्या आहेत. त्यापैकीच एक आहे तत्कालीन परभणी जिल्हयातील वसमत तालुक्यातील गुडा या गावची. 

एके रात्री शेकडो सशस्त्र रझाकार गावावर चाल करून आले. त्यांनी गाव घेरले. गावात जेवढी माणसे सापडली ती पकडून एका विहिरीत टाकली. त्यात कडबा टाकला आणि तो पेटवून दिला. त्याखाली दबलेली सगळी माणसे मेली. नंतर रझाकारांनी सर्व गाव जाळून टाकले. गावातले जे चार-पाच लोक वाचले. ते केवळ ते त्यावेळी बाहेरगावी गेले होते म्हणून. बाकी सर्व गाव संपले. 

हे एक प्रातिनिधिक उदाहरण म्हणून मांडले आहे. अशा शेकडो घटना घडत होत्या. त्यांचा प्रतिकार करण्यासाठी गावागावांत लोकांनी एकजूट उभी केली. रझाकारांचा धैर्याने सामना केला. सामान्य लोकांपासून ते नेत्यांपर्यंत सर्वांनाच ऐका गोष्टीची जाणीव होती की हा असामान्य लढा आहे. या लढ्यात एक तर निजामाचे संस्थान समाप्त होईल किंवा भारतीय राष्ट्राच्या ठिकऱ्या उडतील. 

बॉंबे हायकोर्टाचे निवृत्त न्यायमूर्ती नरेंद्र चपळगावकर यांनी आपल्या 'कहाणी हैदराबाद लढ्याची' पुस्तकात नमूद केले आहे, 

"हिंदूंना त्यांचे धार्मिक आणि सांस्कृतिक अधिकार नाकारल्यामुळे हिंदू-मुस्लिमांत दरी वाढू लागली. हिंदू जनता  केवळ जागरूकतेअभावी आपल्या हक्कांच्या मागणीबाबत आग्रही नव्हती." 
तसेच, 
"संस्थानात जातीय दंगली १९३० नंतर सुरु झाल्या. याचा अर्थ त्यापूर्वी जातीय सामंजस्य होते असा नाही. मुकाट्याने लोक अन्याय सहन करत. त्यामुळे दंगल होण्याचा प्रश्न नसे." 

संस्थानातील शिक्षित हिंदू तरुणांनी सामाजिक जागृतीसाठी अनेक कार्यक्रम हाती घेतले. लोकमान्य टिळकांच्या प्रेरणेने सुरु झालेला सार्वजनिक गणेशोत्सव आणि इतर सामाजिक कार्यांसाठी लोकसंगठन सुरु केले. त्यातून आजही कार्यरत असणाऱ्या सामाजिक आणि शैक्षणिक संस्था सुरु झाल्या. औरंगाबादची सरस्वती भुवन शिक्षण संस्था, परभणी, सेलू आणि बिदर येथी नूतन शिक्षण संस्था तसेच हैदराबादमधील विवेक वर्धिनी या काही प्रमुख संस्था आहेत. तसेच समाजाला जागृत करण्याच्या दृष्टीने १९०१ मध्ये स्थापन झालेल्या परभणीतील गणेश वाचनालयाने उत्कृष्ट कार्य केले. न्यायमूर्ती चपळगावकर यांनी नमूद केले आहे, 

"पुढे ज्या कार्यकर्त्यांनी राजकीय चळवळीत भाग घेतला व तुरुंगवासही भोगला असे कार्यकर्ते आपल्या सार्वजनिक जीवनाच्या प्रारंभीच्या काळात खासगी शिक्षणसंस्था, वाचनालये, सार्वजनिक गणेशोत्सव यांच्या माध्यमातूनच तयार झाले होते."

१९३० पर्यंत हिंदू समाज जागृत होऊ लागला होता. आपल्या हक्कांची उघडपणे मागणी करू लागला होता. शिक्षित तरुण वर्ग सामाजिक कार्याकडून राजकीय मागण्या आणि त्यासाठी संघर्ष या टप्प्यापर्यंत येऊन ठेपला होता. या टप्प्यावर त्यांना एका निस्पृह, खमक्या नेत्याची गरज भासत होती. स्वामी रामानंद तीर्थ यांच्या रूपात तसा निःस्पृह नेता या आंदोलनाला मिळाला आणि आंदोलनाची धार वाढली. नरहर कुरुंदकर यांनी हैदराबाद लढ्यातील स्वामीजींचे महत्व विशद केले आहे ते असे, 

"संस्थानी राजवटीत वीस लक्ष मुसलमानांचे हितसंबंध गुंतलेले असल्यामुळे आक्रमक जातीयवादाच्या चौरस वातावरणात अत्याचार सहन करीतच काम करणे भाग होते. आणि दीर्घकाळच्या मागासलेपणामुळे बहुसंख्य जनता इतकी प्रतिकारशून्य झाली होती, की त्यांना लढ्याची कल्पनाच सहन होत नसे. अशा वातावरणात चारित्र्य, धैर्य आणि बलिदानाची सिद्धता हेच राजकारणाचे आधार होते. अशा राजकारणाचा नेता फक्त संन्यासीच होऊ शकतो, तसा तो झाला."

आंदोलनाची प्रत्यक्ष सुरुवात करण्याचा मान उस्मानिया विद्यापीठातील हिंदू विद्यार्थ्यांना जातो. १९३८ साली विद्यापीठातील हिंदू विद्यार्थ्यांनी प्रार्थनेसाठी जागेची मागणी केली. त्यानुसार नित्य पूजा वगैरेंसोबत 'वंदे मातरम' चेही गायन होऊ लागले. त्याला मुस्लिम विद्यार्थी आणि विद्यापीठ प्रशासनाने हरकत घेतली. यातूनच विद्यापीठातील 'वंदे मातरम' आंदोलनाची सुरुवात झाली. या आंदोलनाची बातमी सर्वदूर पसरली. ठिकठिकाणच्या शाळा आणि महाविद्यालयांत वंदे मातरमचे गायन सुरू झाले. होणाऱ्या कारवाईचा निषेध म्हणून अनेक विद्यार्थ्यांनी महाविद्यालयांतून आपली नावे काढली. यातील अनेक विद्यार्थ्यांना नागपूर विद्यापीठाने सामावून घेतले. १९३८ सालच्या विद्यार्थ्यांच्या आंदोलनामुळे सर्वव्यापी आंदोलनाची ठिणगी पडली. 

त्याच दरम्यान महात्मा गांधींच्या मार्गदर्शनखाली हैदराबाद स्टेट काँग्रेसची स्थापना झाली. परभणीतील प्रतिष्ठित वकील गोविंदराव नानल हे स्टेट काँग्रेसचे पहिले अध्यक्ष झाले. आणि विविध संस्था, संघटनांच्या नेतृत्वाखाली संस्थानात जनआंदोलने सुरू झाली. 

संस्थानी प्रजेत मोठ्या प्रमाणात जागृती निर्माण करणाऱ्या आर्य समाजाच्या नेतृत्वाखालील आंदोलनाला १९३८ साली प्रारंभ झाला. आर्य समाजाने जुलमी शासन संस्था तसेच रझाकारांसारख्या धर्मांध, सशस्त्र संघटनेविरुद्ध, थेट भिडण्याचे धोरण अवलंबले. या काळात आर्य समाजाने बळाने पळवून नेण्यात आलेल्या शेकडो हिंदू स्त्रियांना सोडवून आणले. 

१९३८ सालीच संस्थानात अखिल भारतीय हिंदू महासभेच्या विचारांवर चालणाऱ्या हिंदू सिव्हिल लिबर्टीज सोसायटी या संस्थेने हिंदूंच्या धार्मिक हक्कांसाठी सत्याग्रहाच्या मार्गाने आंदोलन सुरू केले. पुढे १९३९ मध्ये स्वातंत्र्यवीर सावरकरांच्या नेतृत्वाखालील हिंदू महासभेने या आंदोलनात प्रत्यस्ख सहभाग घेतला. तो भागानगरचा सत्याग्रह म्हणून सर्वज्ञात आहे. 

महात्मा गांधींनी अखिल भारतीय पातळीवर वैयक्तिक सत्याग्रहाचा प्रयोग १९४० सालात केला, परंतु हा प्रयोग हैदराबाद संस्थानात १९३९ सालातच करण्यात आला होता. स्टेट काँग्रेसच्या पहिल्या सत्याग्रहात गांधीजींनी वैयक्तिक सत्याग्रहाचा प्रयोग केला, त्यात पहिले सत्याग्रही म्हणून स्वामी रामानंद तीर्थ यांनी सहभाग घेतला. या सत्याग्रहातच स्वामीजींना अटक झाली. पहिला प्रदीर्घ तुरुंगवास झाला.१९४० साली महात्मा गांधींनी स्टेट काँग्रेसला हे आंदोलन मागे घेण्याचा सल्ला दिला. संस्थानात एकाच वेळी आर्य समाज, हिंदू महासभा आणि स्टेट काँग्रेसच्या नेतृत्वाखाली आंदोलने सुरु आहेत. आर्य समाज आणि हिंदू महासभेने धार्मिक हक्कांची मागणी प्रामुख्याने केली आहे. या पार्श्वभूमीवर या आंदोलनाला जातीयवादी ठरवणे आणि त्यादृष्टीने ते दाबून टाकणे निजाम सरकारला अधिक सोपे होईल, अशी कारणमीमांसा गांधीजींनी मांडली. 

जनआंदोलनच्या या पहिल्या पर्वानंतर संस्थानात ठिकठकाणी स्थानिक पातळीवर रझाकारांचे अत्याचार आणि गावपातळीवर एकजुटीने होणारा प्रतिकार हे प्रकार सुरू राहिले. गाव पातळीवर, "जमेल त्याने गोळी खावी, न जमणाऱ्याने पाणी पाजावे. तेही न जमले तर शांतपणे घरच्या घरी डोळे पुसावे. पण शत्रूचा खबऱ्या होऊ नये." हा मंत्र शिरसावंद्य मानून सामान्य जनतेने लढा दिला. 

१९४७ साली ब्रिटिश संसदेने पारित केलेल्या इंडिया इंडिपेन्डन्स बिल मुळे संस्थानिकांना तीन पर्याय मिळाले. भारतात विलीन होणे, पाकिस्तानात विलीन होणे किंवा स्वतंत्र होणे. पण नव्याने स्थापन झालेल्या स्टेट्स खात्याअंतर्गत सरदार पटेल आणि सचिव व्ही. पी. मेनन यांनी वाटाघाटी करून ५५० पेक्षा जास्त संस्थाने १५ ऑगस्ट १९४७ पूर्वीच विलीन करून घेतली होती. फक्त तीन संस्थानांत काही वेगळे मार्ग अवलंबावे लागले. जनआंदोलने झाली. ती संस्थाने म्हणजे जुनागड, काश्मीर आणि हैदराबाद. 

निजाम आणि त्यांचे सल्लागार ब्रिटिश इंडियन सरकार आणि त्यानंतर स्वतंत्र भारताच्या सरकारशी वाटाघाटी करत होते. स्वतंत्र भारत सरकार आणि निजाम स्टेट यांच्यात ऑक्टोबर १९४७ मध्ये 'जैसे थे' करार झाला. त्यानुसार निजाम स्टेट स्वायत्त राज्य म्हणून राखण्यास मान्यता देण्यात आली होती. या कराराच्या मसुदा निश्चितीमध्ये निजामाचे घटनात्मक सल्लागार आलियावर जंग (जे पुढे महाराष्ट्राचे राज्यपाल झाले) यांची महत्त्वाची भूमिका होती. 

१९११ साली राज्यारोहण झाल्यापासून निजामाची हैदराबाद हे स्वतंत्र, सार्वभौम राष्ट्र करण्याची महत्त्वाकांक्षा होती. त्यासाठी निजामाने राष्ट्रीय तसेच आंतरराष्ट्रीय पातळीवर अनेक प्रयत्न केले होते. इराण, तुर्कस्तान, अमेरिका, फ्रांस, इंग्लंड, अर्जेंटिना आणि इतर अनेक राष्ट्रांची स्वतंत्र हैदराबादला मान्यता मिळेल यासाठी दबावगट निर्माण केले होते. निजामाने राज्याची बांधणी त्यादृष्टीने करत आणली होती. जैसे थे करारानंतर एका बाजूला वाटाघाटी लांबवत असताना निजामाने हैदराबादचा प्रश्न थेट संयुक्त राष्ट्र सुरक्षा परिषदेकडे नेण्याचा घाट घातला. हा प्रश्न सुरक्षा परिषदेकडे नेण्याची घाई आणि भारतीय विमानांना हैदराबाद राज्याची हवाई सीमा बंद करण्याचा आदेश या आततायी निर्णयांमुळे भारत सरकारने हैदराबादचा प्रश्न तातडीने सोडवण्याच्या दृष्टीने पाऊले उचलली. 

या दरम्यान हैदराबाद मुक्ती संग्राम लढ्याचे अध्वर्यू स्वामी रामानंद तीर्थ, दिगंबरराव बिंदू यांनी सरदार पटेल यांची भेट घेतली होती. त्यावेळी सरदार पटेल यांनी, 

"जोवर ब्रिटिश गव्हर्नर जनरल भारतात आहेत आणि ब्रिटिश सैन्याधिकारी भारतीय सैन्याचे नेतृत्व करत आहेत तोवर लष्करी बळाद्वारे हैदराबादचा प्रश्न सोडवण्याच्या दृष्टीने भारत सरकार फार काही करू शकत नाही. या परिस्थितीत बदल होईपर्यंत स्टेट काँग्रेसला आपला लढा सुरू ठेवावा लागेल." 

असे उद्गार काढले. थोडक्यात सरदार पटेलांनी हे स्पष्ट केले की ब्रिटिश सैन्य आणि गव्हर्नर जनरल या व्यवस्थेत निजामाला छुपा पाठिंबा मिळण्याची शक्यता आहे. पण ही गोष्ट तितकीच स्पष्ट आहे की जुलै १९४८ मध्ये चक्रवर्ती राजगोपालाचारी यांनी भारताचे पहिले आणि शेवटचे भारतीय गव्हर्नर जनरल म्हणून कार्यभार स्वीकारला आणि जनरल करिअप्पा हे भारतीय सैन्याचे प्रमुख झाले त्यापासूनच्या अडीच महिन्यात 'ऑपरेशन पोलो'च्या सैन्य मार्गाने हैदराबादचा प्रश्न निकालात निघाला. 

१३ सप्टेंबर १९४८ रोजी पोलीस कारवाईला प्रारंभ झाला. चारही बाजुंनी भारतीय सैन्य संस्थानात आगेकूच करत होते. मोठमोठ्या वल्गना करणाऱ्या निजामाच्या सैन्याने आणि धर्मांध रझाकारांनी (ज्यांची संख्या त्यावेळी सुमारे २ लाख होती.) कुठलाही प्रतिकार केला नाही. काही ठिकाणी तुरळक प्रतिकार झाला पण तो तातडीने मोडीत काढत भारतीय सैन्य अवघ्या तीन दिवसात हैदराबाद शहरात पोचले. सामाजिक जागृती, जनआंदोलने, अनेकांचे बलिदान, किचकट वाटाघाटी आणि शेवटी पोलीस कारवाई यामुळे भारताच्या एकीकरणाच्या मार्गातील एक महत्त्वाचा अडसर दूर झाला. तो राष्ट्रीय महत्वाचा दिवस होता १७ सप्टेंबर १९४८. 


- पूर्वप्रसिद्धी: दैनिक मुंबई तरुण भारत 

Tuesday, 28 September 2021

Democracy At Work part 1

 



India i.e. Bharat is a Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic Republic. India has been a miracle for the World. The world, especially the western world was convinced that democracy shall never take its roots in India. According to them the prerequisites for liberal democracy, literacy, meritocracy, a strong foundation of Nation-State are absent. But the fact remains despite having lived under kingdoms for years India and Indian people did possess the most basic factor to make democracy work i.e. an ability to accept the possibility of other views. The Indian ethos believes in "एकम् सत विप्रा: बहुधा वदन्ति." The traces of republics can be traced to the very origin in Vedas. A great historian and writer K. P. Jaiswal has elaborated the forms of ancient Indian republics in his scholarly work 'Hindu Polity.' The modern Constitution of India and laws framed according to it are mere sophisticated forms to make democracy work according to modern needs. 

Intending to decentralizing the power, the Govt. of India constituted multiple committees to suggest, recommend the multi-layered structure of local self-government. According to the recommendations of the Balwantrai Mehta committee, the Three-layered structure of local self-government was introduced and implemented in India. The Gram Panchayat, Panchayat Samiti at Block level, and Zila Parishad at the district level. Some state governments adopted different models according to their needs, and suitability. However, the basic model is mostly similar across the country. Keeping this in mind it has to be noted and considered that Tribal communities constitute a significant chunk of the total population in many states of India. 

The constitution of India in Schedule 5 and Schedule 6 provide for special provisions concerning the administration of tribal areas in various states. The tribal communities mostly are situated in remote areas with dense forests. Their livelihood is dependent upon the jungles and jungle lands for hundreds of years. However, the British period in India saw a major change in the life of the tribal belts in India. The British era laws like Indian Forest Act disassociated the tribal from their livelihood, the jungles. The original, rightful protectors, owners of the jungle became intruders. It had to be changed after the independence of India. It took 49 years to make efforts at legislative level to come up with a statute like PESA i.e. Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996. 

The act provides for a Gram Sabha that consisting of persons whose names are included in the electoral rolls for the Panchayat. Every Gram Sabha shall be competent to safeguard and preserve the traditions and customs of the people, their cultural identity, Community Resources, and the customary mode of dispute resolution. Every Gram Sabha shall approve plans, programs, projects for social and economic development before such plans, programs, and projects are taken up for implementation by the Panchayat at the village level. There are many such provisions in the act that basically empower the Gram Sabha to control their own affairs. An ideal law according to the vision of 'Gram Swaraj' emphasized by Mahatma Gandhiji. 

In India, the legislation are drafted with care, keeping the development of the common man in perspective. However, the fact remains most of the common people do not know how to use those legislations for their benefit. Either simply just out of ignorance or due to the 'Mai-Baap Sarkar' syndrome imbibed in the social psyche of the people. There is a need to make common people, who are the direct beneficiaries of such legislations, aware, empower, and strengthen to implement such legislation. 

The Jawhar-Mokhada belt in the Palghar district has more than 90% tribal population. The tribes in these areas are Warli, Katkari, and Thakar. These communities live in remote villages, called Pada. The number of households in Pada can be as small as 5-10. Many families who prefer to live in their houses built on their farms alone. The belt faces the issues that most of the remote tribal belts in India face. Lack of literacy, employment opportunities, access to healthcare, and many more. The issue of outmigration for employment is rampant. Even though the area is not quite at distant from the industrially developed regions of Mumbai, Nashik, and Vapi-Valsad in Gujarat, this tribal belt is not developed. The belt receives ample rainfall in the monsoon, but it faces acute water shortage in the summer period. On this background the need for the movements such as 'Vayam' becomes pertinent. 

Vayam, a movement for self-empowerment through democratic means, initiated by Milind Thatte and Deepali Gogate, focuses more on making local tribal communities, Gram Sabhas awake, aware and empowered to manage their affairs using all the constitutional-legislative means available. While doing this they come up with innovative ideas to preserve, protect local culture. Ideas to mitigate various issues through innovative ideas that may cost less, can be implemented through community participation or even at the individual level. I watched a presentation by Milind Thatte on the platform of 'Swaym Talks' and the idea, the movement caught my attention. I decided to visit the place, and study the model, learn as much as possible as to how Democracy is at work there. 

Abhyas Varga at Vayam

Let us go through various programs the Vayam movement conducts. Vayam conducts the Abhyas Varg (Learning session) every month for the representatives of Gram Sabhas of nearby Padas. Where Karyakartas take stock of work done by the Gram Sabha in the previous month. Whether villages conducted the Gram Sabha meeting. Were the legal procedures followed? What issues were discussed, were they resolved, what resolutions were proposed? They conduct a session of representatives explaining and elaborating the provisions of PESA 1996, Gram Panchayat Act of Maharashtra state, and other relevant statutes. All the procedures to be followed while conducting Gram Sabha meetings. How to communicate with government authorities such as Gram Sevak, BDO, Tahsildar, and Sub Divisional Officer, etc. 

I attended the Abhyas Varg at the Vayam campus at Jawhar. while listening to what a Karyakarta was explaining I was observing the village representatives keenly. They were enthusiastic, to learn new things. Many of them had experienced the difference after their empowerment and getting first-hand experience of managing their own affairs. 

During the Abhyas Varga, while taking stock of the previous Gram Sabha of a village, Vayam karyakarta asked the representative whether the Gram Sevak was present for the Gram Sabha meeting? If not then whether the notice of such meeting was sent to him? Whether the minutes of the meeting were duly sent to the Gram Sevak for his sign and stamp? The answer from the village was, No. At this point, I realized why the Vayam movement is different than others after listening to what Vayam karyakarta stated after listening to a No. She said, "We should follow and abide by the constitution, and the law. The law provides that the Gram Sevak being Panchayat Secretary is to be served with the notice of meeting to be conducted, the Gram Sevak shall be present at the meeting to record the proceedings in meetings, if not the Gram Sabha shall maintain the record of minutes and get it duly signed-stamped. We should not go beyond the statutory provisions." 

At this point, I can't resist from comparing the Vayam movement with the so-called people's movement in parts of central India a.k.a. Naxalism or Maoism. Maoist movement call for a complete overhaul of the system of constitutional democracy by violent means called the revolution. On the other hand at Jawhar-Mokhada there is a silent revolution happening within the framework of the constitution which asks the common people to awake, make aware, and empower themselves to use all the statutory provisions for the betterment of their lives. This is how Democracy is at work.... 

Let us go through various innovative programs and my experience with Gram Sabha meeting in the next part of Democracy At Work..

Sunday, 16 May 2021

Tiananmen Square: Making of a Protest


- Vijay Gokhale 




Tiananmen Square has been an important monument, site in the history of China. It has been witness to many incidents that defined China what it is today. One of such important incidents that defined the future of modern China. An incident that still attracts the attention of global media, academicians, intellectuals. The Tiananmen Square incident. Was it a massacre? Was it a genuine attempt to bring Western-style democracy to the People's Republic of China? 

India's former Foreign Secretary Vijay Gokhale's book 'Tiananmen Square: The Making of a Protest' tries to answer many of such questions. This book recalls what led to the gathering of masses at the square, how the movement was dealt with and how China created a narrative to cover up the incident, from a former diplomat's point of view, who was posted in the Indian Embassy in Beijing when entire episode unfolded. 

The book is presented in a style that can resemble with Indian style of theatre. Where in the prologue the 'Sutradhar' sets the stage by setting the background for events to unfold. The author has elaborated on the town and areas around the ancient Forbidden City and Tiananmen square. This elaboration builds a picture of the area where the incident unfolded. 

The Initial two chapters introduce the major characters who play important parts. Deng Xiaoping took over the reins of the People's Republic of China after the demise of Chairman Mao Zedong. The Principal Player, as the title to chapter elaborating the rise of Deng to power, rightly suggests his importance in events that changed China's present and future. The economic ideas of Deng took China to what it is today. However, it has to be noted clearly that how he dealt with the Tiananmen square movement, reestablished the firm grip of CCP on the political system of China. 

The subsequent chapters introduce major leaders in the Politburo who played major parts in 'Making of the Protest.' It is very interesting to notice that it was Deng who refused to acquire the position of Chairman of CCP. Yet he was able to assert that he was the undisputed supreme leader. He initiated the process of disintegration of power. He reemphasized collective responsibility. Administrative powers were delegated to General Secretary and Premier. In the early years of Deng's reign Hu Yaobang was the General Secretary. He had to demit office due to internal party politics to secure the top post. The successor of Hu Yaobang, Zhao Yiyang also had to demit office for poor handling of the Tiananmen square movement. 

The Chapters titled 'Strong clouds on the horizon,'  and 'The lull' deal with the power struggle among Chinese leaders. The points of contention were how to proceed with economic reforms and containing 'Bourgeois liberalism.' The intraparty politics is complicated yet fascinating to read. It shows the general nature of human being hungry for power. 

While dealing the intraparty politics the author has quoted the economic ideas implemented by Deng. The Four Modernizations. The Agriculture sector reform of 'household contract responsibility' gave farmers right to retain profits. Second, Industrial policy that introduced Joint ventures with western capital and companies. In the initial years it yielded considerable economic growth. However, by 1987 the negative circumstances began to show up. Banking and Credit mismanagement, double-digit inflation led to issues at economic fronts. 

The very trigger point turned out to be the idea of electing student bodies in Chinese universities of higher studies. However, the authorities decided not to proceed with it at Chinese University of Science and Technology in Hefei. This decision provided a reason for students to protest. Professor Fang Lizhi stated that the process of modernization shall involve a change in the concept of who will lead political and economic fields. In a way, it was a call for democracy. 

The Chinese authorities acted and tried to curb liberalist thoughts from Professors and intellectuals. This led to more discontent among students. They abandoned classes and started moving to Tiananmen Square. The students and citizens started gathering in huge numbers. 

The students were led by Wu'er Kaixi, a Uighur by ethnicity, and Chai Ling. They had presented their demand from authorities. The demands were simple, better education, job opportunities, elimination of nepotism and greater responsiveness to citizens' needs by govt. The students were limited to these. The author states that the western media started to create an impression that students were seeking western-style democracy. 

When the days passed and no solution could be found from negotiations. There was no unity among student protestors. The moderate leaders of students lost control over the movement and radical elements took over. When there was no going back, on 3rd and 4th June, Deng ordered the forces to act. The author describes the events that unfolded. How rumors among protestors created chaos. Many of the protestors vacated the site. Those who stayed back bore the brunt of forces. 

The author has described the conduct of western media and the USA embassy in Beijing. The USA embassy misjudged the Chinese leadership over handling the incident. The western media wrote half- truth reports based on rumors and dried-up sources. They quoted various numbers of casualties and injured. Here, the author has not given any figure of his own. He has just quoted what western media, declassified files of the USA embassy and others. The author doesn't place any opinion. He keeps it open for readers to draw opinions about the entire incident. 

The author has quoted that a full account (prepared by the Chinese Communist Party) should be read on how CCP has crafted its narrative to suggest that it was a handful who tried to destroy the People's state. It has remained a defining narrative to date. The author quotes that the foreign media in Beijing chased the wrong story. It was not a democratic revolution that was underway. It was a power struggle, and its outcome would have a profound impact on China. 

In the last chapter, the author has dealt with the 'outcomes' of this incident. Deng laid the principles of succession that prevailed for the next thirty years. Chinese leaders carefully studied the fall of the Soviet Union and crafted the political system to intensify the grip of the party over the State. The Chinese leadership could strike balance between American capital in China and keeping American ideas of liberalism at bay. With political stability, Chinese economy grew at unprecedented rates and the standard of living improved. 

The book not just gives an account of the making of a protest but also a glimpse of how Chinese leadership works. China has emerged as a global power. It is necessary to learn about how it reached this stature. There is no doubt that Tiananmen Square has played a major part in the emergence of China. This book is a great tool to do it. 

Monday, 26 April 2021

Age of Pandemics: Chinmay Tumbe

 


The Great Divide.. is the term used to denote the only time in the census history of India where there was negative growth in the population of India. How did it happen? With a warm climate, assured seasonal rains, perennial rivers, resources India has always been a suitable for a large population to settle and grow. To say it precisely, India and Asia have always been a home for more than a fifth or sixth of humankind on the Earth. However, the fact remains that despite of having a large population it had always been stable with continuous wars, famines caused due to droughts, and pandemics. There have been incidences of epidemics, pandemics in India since ancient times but the century from 1817 to 1920 has changed the course of history. These around 103 years led to the Great Divide, forever changes in almost all the sectors of life. The Age of Pandemics, a professor at prestigious IIM-A and author Chinmay Tumbe has termed these years and elaborated it. 

The book begins with the origin of the pandemic and goes on elaborating about global pandemics in ancient and medieval periods including India. The court accounts of Mughal emperors fighting wars in different parts of India, Invaders like Nadir Shah and Ahmedshah Abdali, and diaries, reports of officers of British East India company have provided considerable shreds of evidences of epidemics and pandemics. It is interesting to read first devastating pandemic was recorded in Egypt in 542 BCE. According to the symptoms recorded it proves that it was the plague. Further, the author elaborates on various pandemics across the globe including Plague and other pandemics that created havoc. Wiped out 10-20 percent of populations in various countries. 

The book covers three important diseases that resulted in devastating pandemics for India in the age of pandemics. Cholera, the water-borne disease caused due to bacteria claimed millions of lives in various parts of India. The period dealt with here was politically unstable in India. British East India Company was on the verge of becoming prominent power in India defeating Maratha powers. Troop movement, camps near water bodies erupted huge epidemics. Various European scientists and doctors started studying the factors causing the disease. With the advent of medicines and methods to cure the disease, the mortality due to it came down drastically. However, it is worthy to mention that Indians were hesitant to adopt modern medicines. Europeans, Parsis adopted modern medicines and vaccines. The result was clear when in certain outbreaks mortality rate among Europeans and Parsis was 5-6 percent of infected while average of 20 percent of Indians succumbed to the epidemic. 

Kumbh Mela at Prayag (Pic from Internet)

There are some interesting things to notice regarding Cholera pandemics and their spread across the World. During the 1850s and 60s extensive studies were carried out to find out the reasons, cure for the disease. After studying carefully many experts came to the conclusion that it has its origin in India. It has spread across the world with Indian soldiers, British officers in EIC, and ships sailing from India. In 1860, a sanitation conference was held where according to a report the Yatra at Puri was held responsible for the Cholera outbreak. Another major source of cholera epidemics to spread was identified to be the Kumbh Mela's held every 12 years at Prayag (then Allahabad), Nashik, Ujjain, and Haridwar. There are recorded documents of people returning from Haridwar with 'holy' Gangajal and cholera in northern India. In the Arabian peninsula and Africa it was the Hajj pilgrim that was identified as a prime factor being the spread of the pandemic. Apart from water, clothes were also identified as a factor for the spread of disease. In India, a practice of Muslim pilgrims to gift their unwashed clothes to relatives after returning as a gift from the almighty. 

The pandemic due to Plague in 15th century Europe is well known. In India, there have been Plague epidemics in various parts at various times. Among which the pandemic of 1896-97 was most devastating. The British presidencies of Bombay, United Provinces, and Punjab bore the maximum brunt of it. Princely states of Hyderabad and Mysore saw major outbreaks. To curb the epidemic, the British Indian government passed the 'Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897' which gives immense powers to the state machinery to inspect, search, take criminal actions. It is worthy to note the Union and state governments have imposed this very act with necessary modifications to act on the COVID pandemic. 

Inspection of Residential Areas in Mumbai. (Pic from Internet)

There are many things to take into account about this particular pandemic. This pandemic initially struck the cities of Mumbai (then Bombay), Pune hard. As a quarantine measures people living in cities went to live in farms, villages. However, there are stories of horrors faced by patients and common people in these cities set up outside the city limits. Laxmibai Tilak's autobiography 'Smritichitre' notes these horrors in detail. The author has quoted some lines in the book. It is interesting to note Laxmibai Tilak experienced the Influenza pandemic of 1918-19 or the commonly known as Spanish Flu now (The author strongly objects to call it Spanish Flu. He argues that if it has to identify with the certain geographical area then it has to American Flu..), and horrors of quarantine centers then also. 

The Influenza pandemic of 1918-20 is a very interesting and important chapter to read. It has so many striking similarities with what we are facing now. It claimed more than 40 million Indians within a short span of few months. The horrors of the pandemic exacerbated due to the successive failures of monsoons. Which caused famines. Lack of food due to famines led to undernourishment which led to more infections and mortality. It is interesting to note that despite of so much devastation there are no detailed accounts of medical studies, mortality rates, segregation of deaths, etc. the reason behind this lack of data is political instability (as per British records). These were the years of the end of the Great War, Indian soldiers returning from war fronts, Rowlatt Act, Jalianwala Bagh massacre, Non-Cooperation movement. 

Hospital during 1918-20 Pandemic. (pic from Internet)

There have been lasting impacts of the Age of Pandemics on India. As the subheading of the book suggests it shaped India and the World. The very first but kind of short impact pandemics cause is the rise in Migration. Often short term but sometimes permanent also. The pandemics of the Plague brought changes to town planning. People tended to relocate to areas around the cities, resulting in the rise of suburbs. The author cites examples of advanced town planning, sanitation networks in Sindhu-Saraswati civilization cities. He has also quoted verses from Chanakya's 'Arthshastra' on town planning, sanitation, use of water resources, management of epidemics, etc. It is evident that India and the world also have not learned anything from history. Otherwise, the havoc created by the COVID pandemic could have been averted. 

The pandemics hit the urban centers hard than rural areas. Laborers migrated to cities to seek jobs returned to villages. The Sudden availability of labor resulted in a rapid rise of cooperatives. However, in 1918-19 people returned to villages but of no use. The predominantly agriculture-based economy could add value and nutrition due to the failure of the monsoon. On the other hand in 2020, despite lockdowns it was agriculture allied sector only that witnessed a positive growth rate in production and in exports. The labor in cities got more bargaining power to seek more wages. Participation of women in the workforce rose rapidly. 

The Age of Pandemics from 1817 to 1920 shaped India and the World. However, it is evident that India and the World have not learned from these past experiences of pandemics. The author strongly suggests adding the medical history in the syllabus of medical courses in India. There are fascinating insights on social aspects, research in medicines, vaccines to curb the pandemics. This book has been on market for a year almost now. It is better late than never to read this fascinating book to learn about history, to analyze the present, and be ready for the future. 


Artha and the Civilisation: What Really Drives the Indian Economy

  Any system rests on two principal components. One is the driving force behind the system's construction, and the other is the guiding ...